Australian Capital Territory Bills
[Index]
[Search]
[Download]
[Related Items]
[Help]
This is a Bill, not an Act. For current law, see the Acts databases.
CRIMES (RESTORATIVE JUSTICE) BILL 2004
2004
THE LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY
FOR THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL
TERRITORY
(As presented)
(Attorney-General)
Crimes
(Restorative Justice) Bill 2004
Contents
Page
2004
THE LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY
FOR THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL
TERRITORY
(As presented)
(Attorney-General)
Crimes (Restorative
Justice) Bill 2004
A Bill for
An Act to provide a process of restorative justice for victims, offenders
and the community, and for other purposes
The Legislative Assembly for the Australian Capital Territory enacts as
follows:
This Act is the Crimes (Restorative Justice) Act 2004.
This Act commences on a day fixed by the Minister by written
notice.
Note 1 The naming and commencement provisions automatically commence
on the notification day (see Legislation Act, s 75 (1)).
Note 2 A single day or time may be fixed, or different days or times
may be fixed, for the commencement of different provisions (see Legislation Act,
s 77 (1)).
Note 3 If a provision has not commenced within 6 months beginning on
the notification day, it automatically commences on the first day after that
period (see Legislation Act, s 79).
The dictionary at the end of this Act is part of this Act.
Note 1 The dictionary at the end of this Act defines certain terms
used in this Act, and includes references (signpost definitions)
to other terms defined elsewhere in this Act.
For example, the signpost definition ‘adult
offender—see section 12’ means that the expression
‘adult offender’ is defined in this Act, s 12 and the definition
applies to the entire Act.
Note 2 A definition in the dictionary (including a signpost
definition) applies to the entire Act unless the definition, or another
provision of the Act, provides otherwise or the contrary intention otherwise
appears (see Legislation Act, s 155 and s 156 (1)).
A note included in this Act is explanatory and is not part of this
Act.
Note See Legislation Act, s 127 (1), (4) and (5) for the legal
status of notes.
5 Offences
against Act—application of Criminal Code etc
Other legislation applies in relation to offences against this
Act.
Note 1 Criminal Code
The Criminal Code, ch 2 applies to all offences against this Act (see Code,
pt 2.1).
The chapter sets out the general principles of criminal responsibility
(including burdens of proof and general defences), and defines terms used for
offences to which the Code applies (eg conduct,
intention, recklessness and strict
liability).
Note 2 Penalty units
The Legislation Act, s 133 deals with the meaning of offence penalties that
are expressed in penalty units.
Part
2 Underlying
principles
The objects of this Act are as follows:
(a) to enhance the rights of victims of offences by providing restorative
justice as a way of empowering victims to make decisions about how to repair the
harm done by offences;
(b) to set up a system of restorative justice that brings together
victims, offenders and their personal supporters in a carefully managed, safe
environment;
(c) to ensure that the interests of victims of offences are given high
priority in the administration of restorative justice under this Act;
(d) to enable access to restorative justice at every stage of the criminal
justice process without substituting for the criminal justice system or changing
the normal process of criminal justice;
(e) to enable agencies that have a role in the criminal justice system to
refer offences for restorative justice.
Note Offence includes an offence that is alleged to have been
committed, but has not yet been tried in court, or proven (see s 12).
7 Application
of restorative justice
(1) In deciding how to deal with an offence, a referring entity may
consider whether it is appropriate to refer the offence for restorative justice
before considering other action.
Note Referring entities are listed at table 22. They
represent the agencies responsible for the various stages of the criminal
justice process in relation to an offence.
(2) However, if an offence is referred for restorative justice, the
referral is to have no effect on any other action or proposed action in relation
to the offence or the offender by the referring entity.
Example
Sían is arrested and charged with an offence. The chief police
officer refers the offence for restorative justice. The referral of the offence
does not prevent Sían being required to attend court to answer the
charge.
Note An example is part of the Act, is not exhaustive and may
extend, but does not limit, the meaning of the provision in which it appears
(see Legislation Act, s 126 and s 132).
8 When
restorative justice is available
Restorative justice is available for an offence if all of the following
requirements are satisfied:
(a) there is an eligible victim or eligible parent in relation to the
offence;
(b) the offender is an eligible offender;
(c) the offence is referred for restorative justice by a referring
entity;
(d) the chief executive decides that restorative justice is suitable for
the offence.
Note 1 Victims, parents and offenders are eligible for
restorative justice if they qualify under part 5.
Note 2 The chief executive may only decide that restorative justice
is suitable for an offence according to the requirements of part 7
(see s 10, def).
Note 3 The restorative justice process is provided for by this Act
as follows:
• Pt 5 (Eligibility for restorative justice) deals with eligibility
of victims (or their parents) and offenders for restorative justice
• Pt 6 (Referral for restorative justice) deals with the referral of
offences for restorative justice
• Pt 7 (Suitability for restorative justice) deals with the
suitability of restorative justice for an offence.
• Pt 8 (Restorative justice conferences and agreements) deals with
the calling of restorative justice conferences and the making of restorative
justice agreements for an offence
9 No
obligation to participate
There is no obligation on a victim, a parent of a child victim or an
offender—
(a) to take part in restorative justice; or
(b) to continue to take part in restorative justice after it has
started.
Note Victims (or their parents) and offenders must be given clear
explanations of the purpose and procedures involved in the restorative justice
process before agreeing to take part. In addition, the legal status of the
process and the legal effect of entering into a restorative justice agreement
must be clearly explained to victims (or their parents) and offenders. See the
following:
• s 25 (Explanation of restorative justice)
• s 45 (Explanation for participants)
• s 53 (Explanation of effect of agreement).
10 Definitions—restorative
justice
In this Act:
eligible offender—see section 19.
eligible parent—see section 18.
eligible victim— see section 17.
referred, for restorative justice—an offence is
referred for restorative justice if a referring entity proposes
that consideration be given to whether restorative justice is suitable for the
offence.
referring entity—
(a) see section 22; but
(b) for part 8 (Restorative justice conferences and agreements)—see
section 38; and
(c) for division 9.2 (Reporting and records)—see section
67.
restorative justice means the process of restorative justice
provided under this Act, including a restorative justice conference under this
Act.
suitable—restorative justice is suitable
for an offence, or an eligible victim, parent or offender in relation to
an offence, if the chief executive decides under part 7 that restorative justice
is suitable for the offence, victim, parent or offender.
11 Definitions—child
victim, parent and victim
In this Act:
child victim, of an offence, means a victim of an offence who
is a child.
Note A child is an individual under 18 years old (see
Legislation Act, dict, pt 1, def child).
parent, of a child, means a person with parental
responsibility for the child within the meaning of the Children and Young
People Act 1999, part 2.3 (Parental responsibility).
victim—
(a) has the meaning given by the Victims of Crime Act 1994,
dictionary; and
(b) includes a person who would be a victim if a reference in that Act to
an offence included a reference to an offence that is alleged to
have been committed.
12 Definitions—offences
and offenders
In this Act:
adult offender, in relation to an offence, means an offender
who was an adult when the offence was committed.
Note An adult is an individual who is at least 18
years old (see Legislation Act, dict, pt 1, def adult).
commission, of an offence that is alleged to have been
committed, includes the alleged commission of the offence.
Note Offence is defined to include an offence that is alleged
to have committed. Offender is defined in similar terms. See
definitions of offence and offender in this
section.
domestic violence offence means an offence mentioned in the
Protection Orders Act 2001, section 9 (2) that is committed by an
offender, if the offender directed the behaviour comprising the offence at a
relevant person within the meaning of that Act, dictionary in relation to the
offender.
Note Under the Protection Orders Act 2001, dict, a
relevant person in relation to the offender would be any of the
following people:
• a domestic partner of the offender (domestic partner
is defined in the Legislation Act, s 169 (1))
• a relative of the offender (relative is defined in
the Protection Orders Act 2001, dict)
• a child of a domestic partner of the offender
• someone who normally lives, or normally lived, in the same
household as the offender (other than as a tenant or boarder).
less serious offence means an offence other than a serious
offence.
offence—
(a) means an offence against a Territory law; and
(b) includes an offence against a Territory law that is alleged to have
been committed by a person, unless—
(i) a court has acquitted the person of the offence; or
(ii) a court has dismissed a proceeding against the person for the offence
without finding the person guilty.
offender—
(a) means a person who has been convicted or found guilty of an offence
against a Territory law; and
(b) includes a person who is alleged to have committed an offence against
a Territory law, unless—
(i) a court has acquitted the person of the offence; or
(ii) a court has dismissed a proceeding against the person for the offence
without finding the person guilty.
serious offence means an offence punishable by imprisonment
for a term exceeding—
(a) if the offence relates to money or other property—14 years;
or
(b) in any other case—10 years.
young offender, in relation to an offence, means an offender
who was less than 18 years old, but at least 10 years old, when the offence was
committed or allegedly committed.
13 Definition—sentence-related
order
In this Act:
sentence-related order, for an offender who is found guilty
of an offence, means—
(a) for an adult offender, any of the following orders of the
court:
(i) an order sentencing the offender;
(ii) an order under the Crimes Act 1900, section 402 (1) or section
403 (1), including an order dismissing the charge against the offender under
section 402 (1);
(b) for a young offender, any of the following orders under the
Children and Young People Act 1999:
(i) an order under that Act, section 96 (Disposition of young
offenders);
(ii) an order dismissing the charge under that Act, section 98 (2)
(a) (Disposition without proceeding to conviction);
(iii) an order under that Act, section 98 (2) (b).
Examples for par (a)
(i)
1 an order for a sentence of imprisonment
2 a home detention order under the Rehabilitation of Offenders (Interim)
Act 2002
3 a periodic detention order under the Periodic Detention Act
1995
4 an order under the Crimes Act 1900 for the offender to carry out
community service work
Note An example is part of the Act, is not exhaustive and may
extend, but does not limit, the meaning of the provision in which it appears
(see Legislation Act, s 126 and s 132).
Part
4 Application of Act
14 Application
of Act—young offenders and less serious offences
(1) This Act applies to a less serious offence committed by a young
offender.
(2) This Act applies to a less serious offence committed by a young
offender even if the offence was committed before the day this section
commenced.
(3) Despite subsections (1) and (2), this Act does not apply to a domestic
violence offence, or a less serious sexual offence, before the phase 2
application day.
(4) Subsections (2) to (6) (including this subsection) expire on the
phase 2 application day.
Note A provision of an Act expires at the end of the day fixed for
its expiry (see Legislation Act, s 85 (3); repeal in s 85 includes
expiry—see s 82).
(5) Subsections (2) to (6) (including this subsection) are laws to which
the Legislation Act, section 88 (Repeal does not end effect of transitional laws
etc) applies.
(6) In this section:
less serious sexual offence means an offence against any of
the following provisions of the Crimes Act 1900:
(a) section 59 (Act of indecency in the third degree);
(b) section 60 (Act of indecency without consent);
(c) section 61 (2) (Acts of indecency with young people);
(d) section 62 (3) (Incest and similar offences);
(e) section 63 (Abduction).
phase 2 application day—see section 15 (4).
15 Application
of Act—generally
(1) This Act applies to a less serious offence committed by an adult
offender.
(2) This Act applies to a serious offence (whether committed by a young
offender or an adult offender) if—
(a) the offender is charged with the offence; and
(b) either—
(i) the offender pleads guilty to the offence; or
(ii) the offender is found guilty of the offence (whether or not the
offender is convicted or sentenced for the offence).
(3) This section does not apply to a domestic violence offence.
Note For the application of the Act to domestic violence offences,
see s 16.
(4) Subsections (1), (2) and (3) do not apply before a day (the
phase 2 application day) declared by the Minister by written
notice.
(5) However, subsections (1) and (2) may apply to an offence even if the
offence was committed before the phase 2 application day.
(6) A declaration under subsection (4) is a notifiable
instrument.
Note A notifiable instrument must be notified under the Legislation
Act.
(7) To remove any doubt, the Legislation Act, section 79 (Automatic
commencement of postponed law) does not apply to subsections (1), (2) and
(3).
Note If the Legislation Act, s 79 applied to subsection (1), (2) or
(3), the subsection would automatically commence 6 months after the commencement
of this Act (apart from s 1 and s 2) if it had not already been effectively
commenced by the declaration of the phase 2 application day.
(8) Subsections (4) to (9) (including this subsection) expire on the
phase 2 application day.
Note A provision of an Act expires at the end of the day fixed for
its expiry (see Legislation Act, s 85 (3); repeal in s 85 includes
expiry—see s 82).
(9) Subsections (4) to (8), and this subsection, are laws to which the
Legislation Act, section 88 (Repeal does not end effect of transitional laws
etc) applies.
16 Application
of Act—domestic violence offences
(1) This Act applies to a domestic violence offence committed by a young
offender.
(2) Subsection (1) applies whether or not the young offender is charged
with the offence.
Note 1 An offence may have been committed if it is
alleged that the offence was committed (see s 12, def
commission).
Note 2 For the chief executive to decide that a domestic violence
offence committed (or allegedly committed) by a young offender is suitable for
restorative justice under pt 7, the chief executive must be satisfied that
exceptional circumstances exist for the calling of a restorative justice
conference (see s 33 (2)).
(3) This Act applies to a domestic violence offence committed by an adult
offender if—
(a) the offender is charged with the offence; and
(b) either—
(i) the offender pleads guilty to the offence; or
(ii) the offender is found guilty of the offence (whether or not the
offender is convicted or sentenced for the offence).
(4) Subsections (1), (2) and (3) do not apply before the phase 2
application day.
(5) However, subsections (1), (2) and (3) may apply to an offence even if
the offence was committed before the phase 2 application day.
(6) To remove any doubt, the Legislation Act, section 79 (Automatic
commencement of postponed law) does not apply to subsection (1), (2) or
(3).
Note If the Legislation Act, s 79 applied to subsection (1), (2) or
(3), the subsection would automatically commence 6 months after the commencement
of this Act (apart from s 1 and s 2) if it had not already been effectively
commenced by the declaration of the phase 2 application day.
(7) Subsections (4) to (9) (including this subsection) expire on the
phase 2 application day.
Note A provision of an Act expires at the end of the day fixed for
its expiry (see Legislation Act, s 85 (3); repeal in s 85 includes
expiry—see s 82).
(8) Subsections (4) to (9) (including this subsection) are laws to which
the Legislation Act, section 88 (Repeal does not end effect of transitional laws
etc) applies.
(9) In this section:
phase 2 application day—see section 15
(4).
Part
5 Eligibility for restorative
justice
(1) A victim of an offence is eligible for restorative justice in relation
to the offence if—
(a) this Act applies to the offence and the offender under part 4;
and
(b) the victim is at least 10 years old; and
(c) the victim is capable of agreeing to take part in restorative
justice.
(2) If a victim of an offence is younger than 10 years old, an immediate
family member of the victim is eligible for restorative justice in relation to
the offence if—
(a) this Act applies to the offence and the offender under part 4;
and
(b) the immediate family member is at least 10 years old; and
(c) the immediate family member is capable of agreeing to take part in
restorative justice.
Note Alternatively, a parent of a child victim of an offence may
take part in restorative justice as an invited participant (see s 44).
(3) For this Act, a victim of an offence, or an immediate family member of
a victim of an offence, is an eligible victim in relation to the
offence if the victim or immediate family member is eligible for restorative
justice under this section.
(4) In this section:
immediate family member, in relation to a victim of an
offence, means a person who was, at the time the offence was
committed—
(a) a parent of the victim; or
(b) a sibling of the victim.
Examples of siblings
1 brother or sister
2 half-brother or half-sister
3 step-brother or step-sister
4 someone who has the same guardian or foster parent as the
victim
Note An example is part of the Act, is
not exhaustive and may extend, but does not limit, the meaning of the provision
in which it appears (see Legislation Act, s 126 and s
132).
(1) A parent of a child victim of an offence (no matter how old the child
victim is) is eligible for restorative justice in relation to the offence
if—
(a) this Act applies to the offence and the offender under
part 4;
and
(b) the child victim is incapable of adequately understanding or
responding to the experience of the offence, or has died; and
(c) the parent is capable of agreeing to take part in restorative
justice.
(2) For this Act, a parent of a child victim of an offence is an
eligible parent in relation to the offence if the parent is
eligible for restorative justice under this section.
(1) An offender who commits an offence is eligible for restorative justice
if—
(a) this Act applies to the offence and the offender under
part 4;
and
(b) the offender—
(i) accepts responsibility for the commission of the offence;
and
(ii) was at least 10 years old when the offence was committed, or was
allegedly committed; and
(iii) is capable of agreeing to take part in restorative justice;
and
(iv) agrees to take part in restorative justice.
(2) For this Act an offender is an eligible offender in
relation to the offence if the offender is eligible for restorative justice
under this section.
20 Accepting
responsibility for offences
(1) If an offender accepts responsibility for the commission of an offence
to take part in restorative justice, this Act does not prevent the offender from
pleading not guilty for the offence.
(2) The fact that a court knows that an offender has accepted
responsibility for the commission of an offence to take part in restorative
justice does not require a court to reduce the severity of any sentence it may
make for the offender.
Note 1 To be eligible take part in restorative justice, an offender
must accept responsibility for the commission of the offence (see s
19).
Note 2 The Crimes Act 1900, s 342 (1) (v) provides that in
deciding the sentence to be imposed on a person for an offence, the matters to
which a court must have regard include the fact (if true) that the person has
accepted responsibility for the commission of the offence to take part in
restorative justice.
However, the Crimes Act 1900, s 344 (g) provides that a
court must not increase the severity of the sentence that it would otherwise
impose on a person for an offence because the offender has chosen not to take
part, or to continue to take part, in restorative justice for the
offence.
Part
6 Referral for restorative
justice
In this Act:
chief executive (children and young people)—see section
22 (2).
chief executive (corrections)—see section 22
(2).
chief executive (restorative justice)—see section 22
(2).
court referral order—see section 27 (2) (Referral
during court proceeding).
Note Referred is defined in s 10.
referring entity—see section 22.
section 24 referral conditions—see section 24 (Referral
power).
(1) An entity mentioned in table 22, column 2 (a referring
entity) may refer an offence for restorative justice at the stage of the
criminal justice process described for the entity in column 3 in relation to the
offence.
(2) In table 22:
chief executive (children and young people) means the chief
executive of the administrative unit responsible for the administration of the
Children and Young People Act 1999, acting in that capacity.
chief executive (corrections), in relation to an offender for
whom a sentence-related order is made, means the chief executive of the
administrative unit responsible for the administration of the order, acting in
that capacity.
chief executive (restorative justice) means the chief
executive of the administrative unit responsible for the administration of this
Act, acting in that capacity.
Example (definitions of all chief
executives)
For this example, the administrative unit responsible for the
administration of sentence-related orders (for both young and adult offenders)
is also the administrative unit responsible for the administration of this Act
and the Children and Young People Act 1999. The administrative unit has
a single chief executive. That chief executive, in different capacities
corresponding to those different responsibilities, may be differently described
as follows:
• The chief executive is the chief executive (children and
young people) while exercising a function in relation to an offence
allegedly committed by a child who is the subject of a care and protection order
under the Children and Young People Act 1999.
• The chief executive is the chief executive (corrections)
while exercising a function in relation to a young or adult offender who
is the subject of a sentence-related order.
• The chief executive is the chief executive (restorative
justice) while exercising a function relating to the administration of
this Act.
Note 1 If this Act refers simply to the chief
executive (without a tag) this is a reference to the chief executive of
the administrative unit responsible for the administration of this Act (see
Legislation Act, s 163).
Note 2 A chief executive may delegate any powers given to the chief
executive under this Act to a public sector officer under the Public Sector
Management Act 1994, s 36.
Note 3 An example is part of the Act, is not exhaustive and may
extend, but does not limit, the meaning of the provision in which it appears
(see Legislation Act, s 126 and s 132).
prosecution referral, for an offender, means referral of the
offender for prosecution by any of the following:
(a) a voluntary agreement to attend court;
(b) a court attendance notice;
(c) a summons;
(d) the arrest and charging of the offender.
Table 22 Referring entities
column 1
item
|
column 2
referring entity
|
column 3
stage of criminal justice
process
|
1
|
chief police officer
chief executive (restorative justice)
chief executive (children and young people)
|
(a) after the offender is cautioned or apprehended; and
(b) before a prosecution referral is made for the offender
|
2
|
director of public prosecutions
|
(a) after a prosecution referral is made for the offender; and
(b) before a second mention hearing for the offence by a court has
begun
|
3
|
Magistrates Court (including the Childrens Court)
Supreme Court
|
unless, or until, the offender pleads guilty to the
offence—
(a) after a second mention hearing for the offence has begun;
and
(b) before the end of a case management hearing or case status inquiry for
the offence
|
4
|
Magistrates Court (including the Childrens Court)
Supreme Court
|
if the offender pleads guilty to, or is found guilty of, the offence—
(a) after the offender pleads guilty to, or is found guilty of, the
offence (whether or not the offender has been convicted or sentenced);
and
(b) before the end of the proceeding
|
5
|
chief executive (corrections)
chief executive (restorative justice)
sentence administration board
|
(a) after a court has made a sentence-related order in relation to the
offender; and
(b) before the end of the term of the sentence-related order or the
sentence (if any) of which it forms part (whichever is later)
|
6
|
referring entity prescribed under the regulations
|
stage of the criminal justice process prescribed under the
regulations
|
(1) The referring entity must give a referral to the chief executive
(restorative justice).
Note Section 72 deals with what happens if the referring entity is
the same chief executive as the chief executive (restorative justice), but the
referral is made by the chief executive as chief executive (corrections) or
chief executive (children and young people).
That section provides that the chief executive must ensure that
appropriate administrative arrangements are made for the referral to be given by
a delegate of the chief executive as chief executive (corrections) or chief
executive (children and young people) to a delegate of the chief executive as
chief executive (restorative justice).
(2) The referral—
(a) must be in writing, stating the grounds for referral; and
(b) if the referring entity is a court—may be in the form of a court
referral order or sentence-related order, or as a condition of a bail
order.
Note If a form is approved under s 73 for this provision, the form
must be used.
(3) This section does not apply if the referring entity is the chief
executive (restorative justice).
Note The referring entity may be the chief executive (restorative
justice) under table 22, item 1 or 5.
(1) A referring entity may refer an offence for restorative justice if the
entity is satisfied that all the following conditions (the section 24
referral conditions) apply:
(a) the offender is an eligible offender;
(b) there is an eligible victim or parent in relation to the
offence;
(c) an explanation has been given under section 25 to all eligible
victims and parents, and the eligible offender, before they agree to take part
in restorative justice.
Note The conditions under which a victim, parent or offender may be
eligible are set out in s 17, s 18 and s 19.
(2) The restorative justice guidelines may prescribe procedures for making
decisions about referrals under subsection (1).
(3) This section is subject to the following sections:
(a) section 26 (Referral by DPP—domestic violence offences by young
offenders;
(b) section 27 (Referral during court proceeding).
25 Explanation
of restorative justice
Before an offence is referred for restorative justice, the referring entity
must ensure that reasonable steps are taken to explain to each eligible victim
and parent, and the offender (in language that the victim, parent or offender
can readily understand)—
(a) the purpose of restorative justice generally and for the particular
offence; and
(b) the nature of restorative justice, including the following:
(i) the nature of a restorative justice conference;
(ii) who may take part in a restorative justice conference;
(iii) the nature of a restorative justice agreement; and
(c) that the person may seek independent legal advice about taking part in
restorative justice; and
(d) that no-one is under an obligation to take part in restorative
justice, or to continue to take part in restorative justice after it has
started; and
(e) if the offender has not entered a plea for the offence—that the
acceptance of responsibility for the commission of the offence by the offender
for the purpose of restorative justice does not prevent the offender from
pleading not guilty for the offence; and
(f) if a sentence-related order has not been made for the
offender—that, if the offender is found guilty of the offence, a court, in
sentencing the offender—
(i) may consider whether the offender accepts responsibility for the
offence to take part in restorative justice, but is not required to reduce the
severity of any sentence as a result; and
(ii) must not consider whether the offender has chosen not to take part,
or not to continue to take part, in restorative justice.
26 Referral
by DPP—domestic violence offences committed by young
offenders
(1) This section applies if the director of public prosecutions is the
referring entity for a domestic violence offence allegedly committed by a young
offender.
(2) The director of public prosecutions may refer the offence for
restorative justice if—
(a) the section 24 referral conditions apply; and
(b) the director has consulted each person who could be an eligible victim
or parent for the offence.
Note This Act does not apply to a domestic violence offence alleged
to have been committed by an adult offender unless the offender pleads guilty to
the offence, or is found guilty of the offence (see s 16).
(3) Subsections (1) and (2) do not apply before the phase 2 application
day.
(4) However, subsections (1) and (2) may apply to an offence even if the
offence was allegedly committed before the phase 2 application day.
(5) To remove any doubt, the Legislation Act, section 79 (Automatic
commencement of postponed law) does not apply to subsection (1) or
(2).
Note If the Legislation Act, s 79 applied to subsection (1) or (2),
the subsection would automatically commence 6 months after the commencement of
this Act (apart from s 1 and s 2) if it had not already been effectively
commenced by the declaration of the phase 2 application day.
(6) Subsections (3) to (8) (including this subsection) expire on the
phase 2 application day.
Note A provision of an Act expires at the end of the day fixed for
its expiry (see Legislation Act, s 85 (3); repeal in s 85 includes
expiry—see s 82).
(7) Subsections (3) to (8) (including this subsection) are laws to which
the Legislation Act, section 88 (Repeal does not end effect of transitional laws
etc) applies.
(8) In this section:
phase 2 application day—see section 15 (4).
Division
6.3 Referral by
courts
27 Referral
during court proceeding
(1) This section applies if—
(a) a court is the referring entity for an offence under table 22, item 3;
and
(b) the prosecution and any lawyer representing the offender agree that
the offence should be referred for restorative justice; and
(c) either—
(i) the court is satisfied that the section 24 referral conditions apply;
or
(ii) the court considers that it is appropriate to refer the offence for
restorative justice, and the court has ensured that explanations have been given
as mentioned in section 25 to each person of whom the court is aware who is
a victim, or a parent of a child victim, of the offence, and the
offender.
(2) The court may by order (a court referral order) adjourn
the proceeding for a stated period, and refer the offence for restorative
justice, on the application of the director of public prosecutions.
(3) The court must ensure that a copy of the court referral order is given
to—
(a) each victim and parent mentioned in subsection (1) (c) (ii);
and
(b) the offender; and
(c) the director of public prosecutions and any lawyer representing the
offender; and
(d) the chief executive.
(4) For the referral of a domestic violence offence alleged to have been
committed by a young offender, the court may make a court referral order only if
it considers that exceptional circumstances exist to justify the
referral.
Note This Act does not apply to a domestic violence offence alleged
to have been committed by an adult offender unless the offender pleads guilty to
the offence, or is found guilty of the offence (see s 16).
(5) Subsection (4) does not apply before the phase 2 application
day.
(6) However, subsection (4) may apply to an offence even if the offence
was allegedly committed before the phase 2 application day.
(7) To remove any doubt, the Legislation Act, section 79 (Automatic
commencement of postponed law) does not apply to subsection (4).
Note If the Legislation Act, s 79 applied to the subsection, it
would automatically commence 6 months after the commencement of this Act (apart
from s 1 and s 2) if it had not already been effectively commenced by the
declaration of the phase 2 application day.
(8) Subsections (5) to (10) (including this subsection) expire on the
phase 2 application day.
Note A provision of an Act expires at the end of the day fixed for
its expiry (see Legislation Act, s 85 (3); repeal in s 85 includes
expiry—see s 82).
(9) Subsections (5) to (10) (including this subsection) are laws to which
the Legislation Act, section 88 (Repeal does not end effect of transitional laws
etc) applies.
(10) In this section:
phase 2 application day—see section 15 (4).
28 Court
referral orders—reports
(1) This section applies if a court makes a court referral order for
section 27 in relation to a proceeding for an offence.
(2) The chief executive must give the court a written report about the
outcome of restorative justice for the offence within the period for which the
proceeding is adjourned under the order.
(3) The report must include a statement of the following in relation to
each victim and parent mentioned in section 27 (1) (c) (ii), and the
offender:
(a) whether the victim, parent or offender is eligible for restorative
justice;
(b) if the victim, parent or offender is eligible for restorative
justice—whether restorative justice is suitable for the victim, parent or
offender;
(c) whether a restorative justice conference was held;
(d) if a restorative justice conference was held—
(i) the extent to which the conference met the objects of this Act;
and
(ii) whether a restorative justice agreement was reached at the
conference.
Note If a form is approved under s
73
for this provision, the form must be
used.
(4) If a restorative justice agreement was reached at a restorative
justice conference for the offence, the report must include a copy of the
agreement.
(5) The chief executive must give a copy of the report to—
(a) each victim and parent mentioned in section 27 (1) (c) (ii);
and
(b) the offender; and
(c) the director of public prosecutions and any lawyer representing the
offender.
Part
7 Suitability for restorative
justice
29 Meaning
of personal characteristics for pt 7
In this part:
personal characteristics, of a victim, or a parent of a child
victim, or offender, means personal characteristics of the victim, parent or
offender that might affect the outcome of restorative justice for the relevant
offence.
Examples
1 age
2 gender
3 social or cultural background
Note An example is part of the Act, is not exhaustive and may
extend, but does not limit, the meaning of the provision in which it appears
(see Legislation Act, s 126 and s 132).
30 Suitability—eligibility
requirement
The chief executive may decide that an offence is suitable for restorative
justice only if satisfied that—
(a) there is an eligible victim or eligible parent for the offence;
and
(b) the offender is an eligible offender.
31 Finding
of eligibility by referring entity
(1) This section applies if, in a referral under section 23
(Referral—procedure), a referring entity states that a person is an
eligible victim, parent, or offender and gives grounds for that
statement.
(2) For this part, the referring entity’s statement—
(a) is sufficient for the chief executive to be satisfied of the fact of
eligibility; but
(b) does not prevent the chief executive from being satisfied that a
victim, parent or offender is not eligible for restorative justice.
(1) The chief executive is responsible for deciding whether restorative
justice is suitable for an offence.
(2) The chief executive may decide whether restorative justice is suitable
for an offence only after considering the following:
(a) the general considerations mentioned in section 33;
(b) suitability for the eligible victim or parent under section 34 or
section 35;
(c) suitability for the offender under section 36.
(3) If the chief executive decides that restorative justice is suitable
for an offence, the chief executive must ask the following for written consent
for a restorative justice conference to be called for the offence:
(a) the eligible victim or parent, or both (if there is an eligible victim
and an eligible parent);
(b) the eligible offender.
Note If a form is approved under s 73 for this provision, the form
must be used.
33 Suitability—general
considerations
(1) In deciding whether restorative justice is suitable for an offence,
the chief executive must consider the following:
(a) any government or administrative policy relating to the treatment of
offences of the relevant kind;
(b) the nature of the offence, including the level of harm caused by or
violence involved in its commission or alleged commission;
(c) the appropriateness of restorative justice at the current stage of the
criminal justice process in relation to the offence;
(d) any potential power imbalance between the people who are to take part
in restorative justice for the offence;
(e) the physical and psychological safety of anyone who is to take part in
restorative justice for the offence.
(2) The chief executive may decide that restorative justice is suitable
for a domestic violence offence committed by a young offender only if satisfied
that exceptional circumstances exist to justify the calling of a restorative
justice conference for the offence.
(3) Subsection (2) does not apply before the phase 2 application
day.
(4) However, subsection (2) may apply to an offence even if the offence
was committed before the phase 2 application day.
(5) To remove any doubt, the Legislation Act, section 79 (Automatic
commencement of postponed law) does not apply to subsection (2).
Note If the Legislation Act, s 79 applied to the subsection, it
would automatically commence 6 months after the commencement of this Act (apart
from s 1 and s 2) if it had not already been effectively commenced by the
declaration of the phase 2 application day.
(6) Subsections (3) to (8) (including this subsection) expire on the
phase 2 application day.
Note A provision of an Act expires at the end of the day fixed for
its expiry (see Legislation Act, s 85 (3); repeal in s 85 includes
expiry—see s 82).
(7) Subsections (3) to (8) (including this subsection) are laws to which
the Legislation Act, section 88 (Repeal does not end effect of transitional laws
etc) applies.
(8) In this section:
phase 2 application day—see section 15 (4).
(1) In deciding whether restorative justice is suitable for an eligible
victim, the chief executive must consider the following:
(a) the victim’s personal characteristics;
(b) the victim’s motivation for taking part in restorative
justice;
(c) the impact of the offence as perceived by the victim.
(2) For this Act, an eligible victim is a suitable victim if
the chief executive decides under section 32 that the victim is suitable for
restorative justice.
35 Suitability—eligible
parents
(1) In deciding whether restorative justice is suitable for an eligible
parent of a child victim, the chief executive must consider the
following:
(a) the relationship between the parent and the child;
(b) the parent’s and the child victim’s personal
characteristics;
(c) the parent’s and the child victim’s motivation for taking
part in restorative justice;
(d) the impact of the offence as perceived by the parent and the child
victim.
(2) For this Act, an eligible parent is a suitable parent if
the chief executive decides under section 32 that the parent is suitable for
restorative justice.
In deciding whether restorative justice is suitable for an offender, the
chief executive must consider the following:
(a) the extent (if any) of the offender’s contrition or remorse for
the offence;
(b) the offender’s personal characteristics;
(c) the offender’s motivation for taking part in restorative
justice;
(d) the impact of the offence as perceived by the
offender.
Part
8 Restorative justice conferences and
agreements
In this part:
required participant, in a restorative justice
conference—see section 42.
restorative justice agreement—see section 50.
substitute participant—see section 43.
suitable parent—see section 35.
suitable victim—see section 34.
38 Meaning
of referring entity—pt 8
(1) In this part:
referring entity—see section 22.
(2) However, if an offence is referred for restorative justice by a court
in making a sentence-related order, referring entity means the
chief executive (corrections).
39 Decision
to call conference
(1) The chief executive may require a restorative justice conference to be
called for an offence if—
(a) the chief executive decides, under section 32
(Suitability—decision) that restorative justice is suitable for the
offence; and
(b) the eligible victim or parent, and the eligible offender, gives
consent under section 32 (3) for the conference to be called.
(2) The chief executive must assign a convenor to a conference called
under this section.
40 Appointment
of convenors
(1) The chief executive may appoint a person as a convenor for this
part.
Note 1 For the making of appointments (including acting
appointments), see Legislation Act, pt 19.3.
Note 2 In particular, an appointment may be made by naming a person
or nominating the occupant of a position (see s 207).
Note 3 Certain Ministerial appointments require consultation with an
Assembly committee and are disallowable (see Legislation Act,
div 19.3.3).
(2) The chief executive may appoint a person as convenor only
if—
(a) the person has the qualifications and experience prescribed under the
regulations; and
(b) if the person is not a lawyer—the chief executive is satisfied
that the convenor has received sufficient legal training—
(i) to advise those who take part in restorative justice of their rights
and duties at law and under this Act; and
(ii) otherwise to perform the functions of a convenor for this
Act.
(3) Subsection (2) (b) does not prevent regulations being made requiring a
convenor to be a lawyer.
(1) The convenor of a restorative justice conference, subject to this
part, may do anything necessary or desirable to be done in relation to calling
the conference, including the following:
(a) consulting a person with knowledge of or experience in a particular
culture;
(b) inviting a person to take part in the conference;
(c) deciding whether the conference should require the participants to
meet in person, or to communicate in any other way;
(d) fixing a time for the conference, and for any continuation of the
conference;
(e) fixing a venue for the conference, if the participants are to meet in
person;
(f) identifying the issues that should be addressed at the
conference;
(g) facilitating the conference;
(h) warning participants about the potentially incriminating nature of any
statement to be made, or being made, at the conference;
(i) facilitating an agreement between the participants;
(j) ensuring that this Act is complied with in relation to the conference
and any agreement;
(k) any other function required under the regulations.
(2) The convenor must carry out the functions mentioned in
subsection (1) in a way that ensures that no-one’s safety, rights or
dignity is compromised.
Division
8.3 Conduct of
conference
(1) A restorative justice conference for an offence must not proceed
unless each of the following takes part in the conference:
(a) a suitable victim or parent, or a substitute participant for a
suitable victim or parent;
(b) the offender.
(2) A person mentioned in subsection (1) who takes part (or who is to take
part) in a restorative justice conference for an offence is a required
participant in the conference for this part.
Note The convenor may invite supporters of the offender and victim
to take part in the conference, and the informant police officer (see
s 44).
43 Substitute
participants
A person (a substitute participant) acting for a suitable
victim or parent may take part in a restorative justice conference instead of
the victim or parent if—
(a) the victim or parent asks for, or agrees to, the substitution;
and
(b) the convenor agrees to the substitution.
Note If the conference results in a restorative justice agreement,
the substitute participant for the victim or parent must sign the agreement, and
is taken to do so on behalf of the victim or parent (see s 52).
(1) Any of the following may take part in a restorative justice conference
if invited by the convenor:
(a) the police officer who is the informant for the offence;
(b) a parent of a suitable victim or the offender;
(c) a family member or domestic partner of a suitable victim, a suitable
parent or the offender;
(d) a person in a domestic relationship with a suitable victim, a suitable
parent or the offender;
(e) anyone else, if—
(i) a suitable victim or parent, or the offender, considers the person can
provide emotional or practical support for the victim, parent or
offender; or
(ii) the convenor considers that the participation of the person would
help to promote the objects of this Act in relation to the conference.
(2) If a required participant asks the convenor to invite a person
mentioned in subsection (1) to take part in the conference, the convenor must
not refuse the request unless the convenor considers, on reasonable grounds,
that to invite the participant would be significantly detrimental to the objects
of this Act in relation to the conference.
(3) If a participant in a restorative justice conference is represented by
someone acting for the participant in a professional capacity, the
representative may not take part in the conference in that capacity.
Examples of people acting for participants
in a professional capacity
1 lawyers
2 victim intercessors
3 offender intercessors
Note An example is part of the Act, is not exhaustive and may
extend, but does not limit, the meaning of the provision in which it appears
(see Legislation Act, s 126 and s 132).
(4) In this section:
domestic relationship—see the Domestic Relationships
Act 1994, section 3 (Interpretation).
Note For the meaning of domestic partner, see
Legislation Act, s 169.
45 Explanation
for participants
Before a restorative justice conference begins, the convenor must ensure
that reasonable steps are taken to explain to each person who is to take part in
the conference (in language that each can readily understand)—
(a) the objects of this Act in relation to the conference, including the
purpose of restorative justice generally and for the particular offence;
and
(b) the nature of restorative justice, including the following:
(i) the nature of a restorative justice conference;
(ii) who may take part in a restorative justice conference;
(iii) the nature of a restorative justice agreement; and
(c) that the person may, before and after the conference is called, seek
independent legal advice about taking part in a restorative justice conference
and about the effect of any restorative justice agreement reached at a
conference; and
(d) that no-one is under an obligation to take part in the conference, or
to continue to take part in conference after it has started; and
(e) if the offender has not entered a plea for the offence—that the
acceptance of responsibility for the commission of the offence by the offender
for the purpose of restorative justice does not prevent the offender from
pleading not guilty to the offence; and
(f) if a sentence-related order has not been made for the
offender—that, if the offender is found guilty of the offence, a court, in
sentencing the offender—
(i) may consider whether the offender accepts responsibility for the
offence to take part in restorative justice, but is not required to reduce the
severity of any sentence as a result; and
(ii) must not consider whether the offender has chosen not to take part,
or not to continue to take part, in restorative justice.
The convenor of a restorative justice conference may conduct the conference
in any form (or combination of forms) consistent with the restorative justice
guidelines that would, in the convenor’s opinion, best
facilitate—
(a) interaction between the participants; and
(b) the promotion of the objects of this Act in relation to the
conference.
Examples of conference
forms
1 face-to-face meeting
2 exchange of written or emailed statements between participants
3 exchange of prerecorded videos between participants
4 teleconferencing
5 videoconferencing
Note An example is part of the Act, is not exhaustive and may
extend, but does not limit, the meaning of the provision in which it appears
(see Legislation Act, s 126 and s 132).
47 Discontinuance
of restorative justice
(1) The convenor of a restorative justice conference may decide
to—
(a) cancel the conference before it is conducted; or
(b) discontinue the conference at any time after it has started.
(2) The convenor may cancel or discontinue the conference only if, in the
convenor’s opinion based on reasonable grounds, there is no significant
prospect of promoting the objects of this Act by conducting, or continuing to
conduct, the conference.
(3) Without limiting subsection (2), the convenor must cancel or
discontinue the conference if, in the convenor’s opinion based on
reasonable grounds, before or during the conference—
(a) a suitable victim or parent has withdrawn his or her agreement to take
part in the conference, and there is no other suitable victim or parent (or
substitute participant for a suitable victim or parent) who agrees to take part
in the conference; or
(b) the offender has withdrawn his or her agreement to take part in the
conference.
(4) If the convenor decides to cancel or discontinue the conference, the
convenor must give notice of the decision to—
(a) each required participant in the conference; and
(b) the referring entity for the offence.
48 Report
to referring entity about outcome
(1) After the end of a restorative justice conference, the convenor must
give a report about the outcome of the conference to the referring entity for
the offence.
(2) The report about the outcome of the conference must include the
following information:
(a) details of the conference and when it ended; and
(b) whether the conference resulted in a restorative justice
agreement.
Note If the conference resulted in an agreement, the convenor must
give a copy of the agreement to the referring entity as well (see s
54).
Division
8.4 Restorative justice
agreements
This division applies in relation to a restorative justice agreement that
results from (or that may result from) a restorative justice
conference.
50 Agreement
as object of conference
A restorative justice conference has as a primary object the formation of
an agreement under this division (a restorative justice agreement)
between each required participant in the conference.
(1) A restorative justice agreement in relation to an offence must include
measures intended to repair the harm caused by the offence.
(2) The agreement may include 1 or more of the following:
(a) an apology by the offender to any victim or parent of a
victim;
(b) a plan to address the offending behaviour of the offender;
(c) a work plan to be carried out by the offender for the benefit of any
victim or parent of a victim;
(d) a work plan to be carried out by the offender for the benefit of the
community or a part of the community;
(e) financial reparation to be paid by the offender to any victim or
parent of a victim;
(f) anything else that each required participant and substitute
participant in the conference agree would help repair the harm caused by the
offence.
(3) The agreement must be fair and, in the opinion of each required
participant and substitute participant in the conference and the convenor,
reasonably able to be carried out by the offender.
(4) The agreement must not require the offender or anyone else to do
anything that would—
(a) be unlawful; or
(b) require the detention of the offender (whether full-time or for any
period); or
(c) be degrading or humiliating to the offender or anyone else;
or
(d) cause distress to the offender or anyone else.
(5) The agreement must be for a term of no longer than 6 months, starting
on—
(a) the date the agreement is made; or
(b) if a later starting date is stated in the agreement—the later
date.
Note The term of the agreement may be extended beyond this period,
or reduced, by an amendment under s 55.
(1) A restorative justice agreement must be—
(a) in writing; and
(b) signed by each required participant in the conference.
(2) If a substitute participant for a suitable victim or parent signs a
restorative justice agreement—
(a) the substitute participant is taken to sign the agreement on behalf of
the victim or parent; and
(b) the victim or parent is taken to have consented to the
agreement.
Note If there is a substitute victim or parent for a restorative
justice conference under s 43, the substitute is a required participant
in the conference (see s 42), and so may sign a restorative justice
agreement under s (1) (b).
53 Explanation
of effect of agreement
Before a restorative justice agreement is signed, the convenor must ensure
that reasonable steps are taken to explain to each required participant in the
conference (in language that each can readily understand)—
(a) the nature, purpose and effect of the agreement; and
(b) that no-one is under an obligation to sign the agreement;
and
(c) that the participant may, before signing the agreement, seek
independent legal advice about the effect of the proposed agreement;
and
(d) if the offender has not entered a plea for the offence—that any
statement in the agreement that the offender accepts responsibility for the
commission of the offence does not prevent the offender from pleading not guilty
to the offence; and
(e) if a sentence-related order has not been made for the
offender—that, if the offender is found guilty of the offence, a court, in
sentencing the offender—
(i) may consider whether the offender accepts responsibility for the
offence to take part in restorative justice, but is not required to reduce the
severity of any sentence as a result; and
(ii) must not consider whether the offender has chosen not to take part,
or not to continue to take part, in restorative justice.
The convenor must give a copy of a restorative justice agreement
to—
(a) each required participant in the conference; and
(b) the referring entity for the offence.
55 Amendment
of agreement
(1) The convenor may amend a restorative justice agreement on the
application of a required participant in the conference, or the convenor’s
initiative, if the convenor considers that the amendment is necessary or
desirable—
(a) to respond to a change in the situation of any suitable victim or
parent, or the offender; or
(b) to correct an error.
(2) Without limiting subsection (1), the convenor may amend a restorative
justice agreement under the subsection in response to a change in the situation
of any suitable victim or parent, or the offender—
(a) to increase the term of the agreement, including an increase that
would provide for the agreement to end more than 6 months after the day it
started under section 51 (5); or
(b) to reduce the term of the agreement.
Example
Sam is an offender, and Bella is a victim of Sam’s offence. Sam is
found guilty of the offence but, under the Crimes Act 1900, s 402 (1),
the charge is dismissed and no conviction is recorded. After taking part in a
restorative justice conference, Sam and Bella sign a restorative justice
agreement under which Sam agrees to work in Bella’s garden every Saturday
for 6 months.
However, 4 months after the start of the agreement, the company Sam works
for moves its head office from Canberra to Brisbane, and Sam is required to move
there before the 6 months is over in order to keep his job. Sam has until then
complied fully with the agreement.
The convenor may consider, because of Sam’s history of compliance
with the agreement, and the change in Sam’s situation, there is a change
in Sam’s situation that would justify an amendment to the agreement to
reduce its term so that it will end when Sam has to move to Brisbane.
Note 1 See s (5), def change in the situation. The
definition excludes a change in the offender’s, victim’s or
parent’s attitude to compliance with the restorative justice
agreement.
Note 2 An example is part of the Act, is not exhaustive and may
extend, but does not limit, the meaning of the provision in which it appears
(see Legislation Act, s 126 and s 132).
(3) However, any amendment of a restorative justice agreement to respond
to a change in the situation of any suitable victim or parent, or the offender,
may only be made after the convenor has consulted each required participant in
the conference who is a suitable victim or parent, or a substitute participant
for a suitable victim or parent.
(4) If the convenor amends a restorative justice agreement under this
section, the convenor must give notice of the amendment and a copy of the
agreement, as amended, to—
(a) each required participant in the conference; and
(b) the referring entity for the offence.
(5) In this section:
change in the situation, of a victim, parent or offender in
relation to a restorative justice agreement, does not include a change in the
victim’s, parent’s or offender’s attitude to complying with
the agreement.
Division
8.5 Monitoring compliance with
restorative justice agreements
This section applies to a restorative justice agreement for an offence that
is referred for restorative justice by a referring entity.
57 Monitoring
compliance—chief executive (restorative justice)
(1) The chief executive (restorative justice) may do anything reasonable
to check whether the restorative justice agreement is being complied
with.
Example
Alex has been convicted and sentenced for an offence. As a condition of
the sentence, Alex has taken part in restorative justice. After a restorative
justice conference, Alex signed a restorative justice agreement with the victim
agreeing to perform 50 hours unpaid work for a charity service organisation.
The chief executive (restorative justice) may, under this subsection, contact
the organisation at reasonable intervals to make sure that Alex performs the
work satisfactorily.
Note An example is part of the Act, is not exhaustive and may
extend, but does not limit, the meaning of the provision in which it appears
(see Legislation Act, s 126 and s 132).
(2) If the chief executive (restorative justice) is satisfied on
reasonable grounds that there has been a significant failure to comply with the
restorative justice agreement, the chief executive must report the noncompliance
to the referring entity.
(3) If the chief executive (restorative justice) is satisfied on
reasonable grounds that the restorative justice agreement has been substantially
or fully complied with, the chief executive must report the compliance to the
referring entity.
(4) Subsections (2) and (3) do not apply if the referring entity is the
chief executive (restorative justice).
Note 1 The referring entity may be the chief executive (restorative
justice) under table 22, item 1 or 5.
Note 2 Section 72 deals with what happens if the referring entity is
the same chief executive as the chief executive (restorative justice), but the
referring entity is the chief executive in his or her capacity as chief
executive (corrections) or chief executive (children and young
people).
That section provides that the chief executive must ensure that
appropriate administrative arrangements are made for the report to be given by a
delegate of the chief executive as chief executive (restorative justice) to a
delegate of the chief executive as chief executive (corrections) or chief
executive (children and young people).
58 Monitoring
compliance—referring entities
(1) The referring entity may do anything reasonable to check whether the
agreement is being complied with.
Example
The example for section 57 (1) applies in relation to the checking of
compliance by the referring entity.
Note An example is part of the Act, is not exhaustive and may
extend, but does not limit, the meaning of the provision in which it appears
(see Legislation Act, s 126 and s 132).
(2) If the referring entity is satisfied on reasonable grounds that there
has been a significant failure to comply with the restorative justice agreement,
the referring entity must report the noncompliance to the chief executive
(restorative justice).
(3) If the referring entity is satisfied on reasonable grounds that the
restorative justice agreement has been substantially or fully complied with, the
referring entity must report the compliance to the chief executive (restorative
justice).
(4) Subsections (2) and (3) do not apply if the referring entity is the
chief executive (restorative justice).
Note 1 The referring entity may be the chief executive (restorative
justice) under s 22, table 22, item 1 or 5.
Note 2 Section 72 deals with what happens if the referring entity is
the same chief executive as the chief executive (restorative justice), but the
referring entity is the chief executive in his or her capacity as chief
executive (corrections) or chief executive (children and young
people).
That section provides that the chief executive must ensure that
appropriate administrative arrangements are made for the report to be given by a
delegate of the chief executive as chief executive (corrections) or chief
executive (children and young people) to a delegate of the chief executive as
chief executive (restorative justice).
Division
8.6 Evidence of statements made at
conferences
(1) This section applies if a statement is made by an offender (the
conference offender) during a restorative justice conference, or
in a restorative justice agreement, in relation to an offence (the
conference offence) that has been committed by anyone (including
the conference offender).
(2) Evidence of the statement may not be admitted in court in a proceeding
in relation to a less serious offence (including the conference offence, if that
is a less serious offence), whether or not the conference offender is accused of
the offence.
(3) However, subsection (2) does not prevent a court, in sentencing an
offender for an offence (whether the offence is a less serious offence or a
serious offence), from considering a statement made by the offender during a
restorative justice conference, or in a restorative justice agreement, in
relation to the offence or any other offence.
Note There may be circumstances in which evidence of the statement
is admissible in court in a proceeding in relation to a serious offence, whether
or not the conference offence is a serious offence, or the conference offender
is accused of the offence. Territory law that deals generally with the
admission of evidence in criminal proceedings would apply.
60 Evidence
of future offences
(1) This section applies if a statement is made by an offender (the
conference offender) during a restorative justice conference, or
in a restorative justice agreement, in relation to an offence (the
conference future offence) proposed to be committed after the time
of the conference or agreement by anyone (including the conference
offender).
(2) This Act does not prevent evidence of the statement being admitted in
court in a proceeding in relation to the conference future
offence—
(a) whether or not the offence is a serious offence; and
(b) whether or not the conference offender intends to commit, or is
alleged to have committed, the offence.
Division
9.1 General
administration
61 Restorative
justice guidelines
(1) The chief executive may issue guidelines (restorative justice
guidelines) outlining procedures for the following:
(a) the referral of offences for restorative justice, including procedures
for making decisions about referrals;
(b) the management of restorative justice;
(c) the conduct of restorative justice conferences;
(d) monitoring the progress of restorative justice;
(e) monitoring compliance with restorative justice agreements;
(f) any other aspect of the administration of this Act.
(2) Restorative justice guidelines—
(a) may deal with matters also dealt with elsewhere under this Act;
but
(b) must not be inconsistent with this Act.
(3) Restorative justice guidelines are disallowable instruments.
Note A disallowable instrument must be notified, and presented to
the Legislative Assembly, under the Legislation Act.
(4) A referring entity for an offence must comply with the
guidelines.
62 Police
participation in restorative justice
The chief executive may make arrangements with the chief police
officer—
(a) for the participation of police officers in the administration of this
Act; and
(b) for the appointment of police officers to call restorative justice
conferences, subject to this Act.
(1) The chief executive may ask a referring entity to give the chief
executive information about a victim, the parent of a victim, an offender or
anyone else if the information is necessary for the administration of this
Act.
(2) A referring entity must do everything reasonable to comply with a
request under subsection (1).
(1) In this section:
secret-keeper means a person who is exercising, or has
exercised, a function under this Act.
Examples
1 a referring entity, or the delegate of a referring entity, if the
referring entity or delegate is considering whether to refer an offence for
restorative justice
2 the chief executive, or a delegate of the chief executive, if the chief
executive or delegate is considering whether an offence is suitable for
restorative justice, or whether a restorative justice conference for an offence
should be called
3 the convenor of a restorative justice conference, if the convenor is
making preparations for a restorative justice conference
4 a staff member of an administrative unit, if the staff member is
assisting a secret-keeper mentioned in examples 1, 2 or 3 in carrying out the
functions mentioned in those examples
Note An example is part of the Act, is not exhaustive and may
extend, but does not limit, the meaning of the provision in which it appears
(see Legislation Act, s 126 and s 132).
protected information—
(a) means information about a person that is disclosed to, or obtained by,
a secret-keeper because of the exercise of a function by the secret-keeper under
this Act; but
(b) does not include information in a restorative justice agreement or
information disclosing who attended a restorative justice conference.
Examples of protected
information
1 information obtained by a referring entity or the chief executive in
assessing the eligibility of a victim, parent or offender for restorative
justice
2 information obtained by the convenor of a restorative justice conference
in preparing the conference
3 a transcript (or other record) of what is said during a restorative
justice conference that is kept by the convenor or the chief executive
(2) A secret-keeper commits an offence if the
secret-keeper—
(a) makes a record of protected information; or
(b) directly or indirectly discloses or communicates protected information
about someone to someone else.
Maximum penalty: 50 penalty units, imprisonment for 6 months or
both.
(3) Subsection (2) does not apply if the record is made, or the
information is disclosed or communicated—
(a) under this or any other Act; or
(b) in relation to the exercise of a function, as a secret-keeper, under
this or any other Act.
(4) Subsection (2) does not prevent a secret-keeper from divulging or
communicating protected information about someone with that person’s
consent.
(5) For a civil proceeding, a secret-keeper must not—
(a) disclose or communicate protected information to a court; or
(b) produce or permit access to a document containing protected
information to a court.
(6) For a criminal proceeding, unless it is necessary to do so to comply
with this Act, any other Territory law or a law of the Commonwealth, a
secret-keeper is not required—
(a) to disclose or communicate protected information to a court;
or
(b) to produce or permit access to a document containing protected
information to a court.
Note The Freedom of Information Act 1989, s 38 (Documents to
which secrecy provisions of enactments apply) provides that a document is exempt
from access requirements under that Act if another Act applies specifically to
information of a particular kind in a document and prohibits the disclosure of
that information by persons mentioned in the other Act. The section is stated
to apply whether or not the prohibition is absolute or subject to exceptions or
qualification.
65 Secrecy
about information acquired under other Acts
(1) The provisions of another Act imposing restrictions or obligations of
secrecy or nondisclosure of information acquired in the administration of that
Act apply to a person who, in the exercise of functions under this Act, has
access to the information because of the information having been acquired in the
administration of the other Act.
(2) For subsection (1), the person who has access to the information
in the exercise of functions under this Act is taken to be a person engaged in
the administration of the other Act.
(3) Subsection (1) does not prevent—
(a) the giving of access to records under this Act; or
(b) the preparation and dissemination of guides and aids to finding
information contained in the records.
66 Protection
from liability
(1) A person is not personally liable for anything done or omitted to be
done honestly and without negligence—
(a) in the exercise of a function under this Act; or
(b) in the reasonable belief that the act or omission was in the exercise
of a function under this Act.
(2) Any liability that, apart from subsection (1), would attach to a
person attaches instead to the Territory.
Division
9.2 Reporting and
records
67 Meaning
of referring entity—div 9.2
(1) In this division:
referring entity, in relation to an offence—see section
22.
(2) However, if an offence is referred for restorative justice by a court
in making a sentence-related order, referring entity means the
chief executive (corrections).
68 Quarterly
reporting by chief executive
(1) This section applies in relation to a quarter of a year
if—
(a) an offence is referred for restorative justice before the start of, or
during, the quarter; and
(b) restorative justice—
(i) has not ended for the offence; or
(ii) ended for the offence during the quarter.
Note Quarter is defined in the Legislation Act, dict, pt 1 to
mean the 3 months following 1 January, 1 April, 1 July or 1 October in any
year.
(2) Within 7 days after the last day of the quarter, the chief executive
(restorative justice) must report to the referring entity on the progress of
restorative justice for the offence during the quarter.
Note Section 72 deals with what happens if the referring entity is
the same chief executive as the chief executive (restorative justice), but the
referring entity is the chief executive in his or her capacity as chief
executive (corrections) or chief executive (children and young
people).
That section provides that the chief executive must ensure that
appropriate administrative arrangements are made for the report to be given by a
delegate of the chief executive as chief executive (restorative justice) to a
delegate of the chief executive as chief executive (corrections) or chief
executive (children and young people).
(3) This section does not apply if the referring entity is the chief
executive (restorative justice).
Note The referring entity may be the chief executive (restorative
justice) under table 22, item 1 or 5.
(4) In this section:
ends—restorative justice ends for an
offence if—
(a) the chief executive decides that restorative justice is not suitable
for the offence; or
(b) the convenor of a restorative justice conference for the offence
discontinues the conference under section 47; or
(c) a restorative justice conference for the offence is
concluded.
Note Restorative justice means the process of restorative
justice provided under this Act, including a restorative justice conference (see
s 10). Restorative justice, apart from the process provided under this Act that
is mentioned in the definition, does not necessarily end as provided in the
definition of ends for this section.
69 Record-keeping
by referring entities
(1) If an offence is referred to the chief executive for restorative
justice, the referring entity must ensure that appropriate records are kept in
relation to—
(a) the circumstances in which the referral was made; and
(b) the progress of restorative justice for the offence; and
(c) the outcome of restorative justice for the offence.
(2) The referring entity must also ensure that a copy of any restorative
justice agreement for the offence (as amended, if at all, under section 55) is
kept as part of the records.
(3) The records mentioned in subsection (1) must be kept as part of the
administrative or court records normally kept by the referring entity in
relation to the offence.
70 Record-keeping
by chief executive
(1) The chief executive must keep records of—
(a) each referral of an offence to the chief executive for restorative
justice; and
(b) any assessment of suitability for restorative justice under
part 7, whether because of a referral of an offence for restorative justice
or in other circumstances; and
(c) each offence for which a restorative justice conference is called;
and
(d) each restorative justice conference that is conducted; and
(e) each restorative justice conference that is cancelled or discontinued;
and
(f) each restorative justice agreement that is reached at a conference;
and
(g) the offender’s compliance with each restorative justice
agreement.
(2) The records mentioned in subsection (1) (g) must be kept in
consultation with the relevant referring entity.
(3) A record of an offence for which a restorative justice agreement is
reached must include a copy of the restorative justice agreement (as amended, if
at all, under section 55).
71 Restorative
justice database
(1) The chief executive must ensure that a database is kept of information
in the records required to be kept under section 70 to enable research,
analysis and evaluation of restorative justice.
(2) The database must be kept in accordance with the
regulations.
(3) Regulations made for this section—
(a) may allow access to the information in the database by anyone for
research, analysis and evaluation of restorative justice; but
(b) must not allow access to the information in the database in any form
that would allow the identity of anyone taking part in restorative justice to be
worked out.
72 Exercise
of functions by chief executive
(1) This section applies if—
(a) section 23, section 57, section 58 or section 68 requires a chief
executive, in the chief executive’s capacity as responsible for a
particular matter (the first capacity) to give a referral or
report to a chief executive, in the chief executive’s capacity as
responsible for another matter (the second capacity);
and
(b) a single chief executive acts in both the first and second
capacities.
(2) A chief executive mentioned in subsection (1) must ensure that
administrative arrangements are made for a delegate of the chief executive in
the first capacity to give the referral or report to a delegate of the chief
executive in the second capacity who is a different person from the delegate in
the first capacity.
Example
Pat has been found guilty of an offence but released on a recognisance
entered into under an order under the Crimes Act 1900, section 402 (1) (a
sentence-related order—see s 12). The offence is referred
for restorative justice by the chief executive (corrections).
After a restorative justice conference, Pat enters into a restorative
justice agreement with the victim of the offence. Under the agreement, Pat
promises to attend a rehabilitation program on a particular night of the week
for 3 months. However, after 2 weeks, Pat breaches the agreement by stopping
attending the program.
The chief executive (restorative justice) becomes aware of the breach of
the agreement. Under section 57 (2), the chief executive (restorative justice)
must report the breach to the referring entity, the chief executive
(corrections). However, the chief executive (restorative justice) is the same
person as the chief executive (corrections).
This section requires the chief executive to ensure that administrative
arrangements are made for the report to be given by a delegate of the chief
executive in the chief executive’s capacity as administering this Act to
someone else who is a delegate of the chief executive in the chief
executive’s capacity as administering sentence-related orders such as the
order for Pat.
Note An example is part of the Act, is not exhaustive and may
extend, but does not limit, the meaning of the provision in which it appears
(see Legislation Act, s 126 and s 132).
(1) The Minister may, in writing, approve forms for this Act.
(2) If the Minister approves a form for a particular purpose, the form
must be used for that purpose.
Note For other provisions about forms, see Legislation Act, s
255.
(3) An approved form is a notifiable instrument.
Note A notifiable instrument must be notified under the Legislation
Act.
74 Regulation-making
power
(1) The Executive may make regulations for this Act.
Note Regulations must be notified, and presented to the Legislative
Assembly, under the Legislation Act.
(2) Without limiting subsection (1), the regulations may make provision in
relation to the following:
(a) referring entities for table 22, item 6;
(b) the qualifications and experience of convenors, for section 40
(2) (a);
(c) the functions of convenors, for section 41 (1) (k);
(d) the keeping of a database of restorative justice information, for
section 71.
(1) The Minister must—
(a) begin a review (the first phase review) of the operation
of restorative justice no later than 18 months after the day this section
commences; and
(b) present a report on the review to the Legislative Assembly within 3
months after the day the review is started.
(2) The Minister must—
(a) begin another review (the second phase review) of the
operation of restorative justice no later than 18 months after the phase 2
application day under section 15 (4); and
(b) present a report on the review to the Legislative Assembly within 3
months after the day the review is started.
(3) The first phase and second phase reviews must include an evaluation of
restorative justice against the following indicators:
(a) victim satisfaction and opportunities for meaningful participation by
victims;
(b) rehabilitation of offenders who have taken part in restorative
justice, including any reduction in recidivism;
(c) community satisfaction;
(d) reintegration of victims and offenders into the community;
(e) respect for the rights of everyone directly involved in restorative
justice, and the rights of others in the community;
(f) recognition of fairness of process and outcome by victims and
offenders.
(4) This section expires on 1 July 2008.
(5) This section is a provision to which the Legislation Act,
section 88 (Repeal does not end effect of transitional laws etc)
applies.
76 Administrative
Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1989, schedule 1, new clause
9
insert
9 This Act does not apply to decisions under the Crimes (Restorative
Justice) Act 2004.
77 Crimes
Act 1900, section 342 (1) (u)
substitute
(u) whether the person has paid the prescribed penalty in accordance with
an offence notice served, under section 441, on him or her for an
offence;
(v) if the person has accepted responsibility for the offence to take part
in restorative justice under the Crimes (Restorative Justice) Act
2004—that fact.
78 Crimes
Act 1900, section 344 (1) (f)
substitute
(f) that the person chose to plead not guilty;
(g) that the offender chose not to take part, or chose not to continue to
take part, in restorative justice for the offence under the Crimes
(Restorative Justice) Act 2004.
79 Crimes
Act 1900, section 364 (1) (k)
substitute
(k) the authorised officer’s opinion about—
(i) the offender’s attitude to the offence; and
(ii) the likelihood that the offender may commit additional offences;
and
(iii) whether it would be appropriate to refer the offender for
restorative justice under the Crimes (Restorative Justice) Act
2004.
(see s 3)
Note 1 The Legislation Act contains definitions and other provisions
relevant to this Act.
Note 2 For example, the Legislation Act, dict, pt 1 defines the
following terms:
• ACT
• adult
• amend
• chief executive (see s 163)
• chief police officer
• child
• Childrens Court
• director of public prosecutions (or DPP)
• domestic partner (see s 169 (1))
• found guilty (of an offence)
• Legislative Assembly
• Magistrates Court
• property
• quarter
• sentence administration board
• sitting day
• Supreme Court
• the Territory.
adult offender—see section 12.
chief executive (children and young people)—see
section 22 (2).
chief executive (corrections)—see section 22
(2).
chief executive (restorative justice)—see section 22
(2).
Note If this Act refers simply to the chief executive,
this is a reference to the chief executive of the administrative unit
responsible for the administration of this Act (see Legislation Act, s
163).
child victim—see section 11.
commission, of an offence that is alleged to have been
committed—see section 12.
convenor means a person appointed as a convenor for part 8
(Restorative justice conferences and agreements) under
section 40.
court referral order—see section 27 (2) (Referral
during court proceeding).
domestic violence offence—see section 12.
eligible offender—see section 19.
eligible parent—see section 18.
eligible victim—see section 17.
less serious offence— see section 12.
objects, of this Act—see section 6.
offence—see section 12.
offender—see section 12.
parent—see section 11.
personal characteristics, of a victim, parent of a victim, or
offender, for part 7 (Suitability for restorative justice)—see section
29.
referred—see section 10.
referring entity—
(a) see section 22; but
(b) for part 8 (Restorative justice conferences and agreements)—see
section 38; and
(c) for division 9.2 (Reporting and records)—see section
67.
required participant, in a restorative justice conference,
for part 8 (Restorative justice conferences and agreements)—see
section 42.
restorative justice—see section 10.
restorative justice agreement—see section 50 (Agreement
as object of conference).
restorative justice conference means a conference called for
part 8 (Restorative justice conferences and agreements).
restorative justice guidelines—see section
61.
section 24 referral conditions—see section 24 (Referral
power).
sentence-related order, for an offender who is found guilty
of an offence—see section 13.
serious offence—see section 12.
substitute participant, for part 8 (Restorative justice
conferences and agreements)—see section 43.
suitable—section 10.
suitable parent—see section 35.
suitable victim—see section 34.
victim—see section 11.
young offender—see section 12.
Endnotes
1 Presentation speech
Presentation speech made in the Legislative Assembly on 2004.
2 Notification
Notified under the Legislation Act on 2004.
3 Republications of amended laws
For the latest republication of amended laws, see
www.legislation.act.gov.au.
© Australian Capital Territory
2004
[Index]
[Search]
[Download]
[Related Items]
[Help]