Australian Capital Territory Bills Explanatory Statements
[Index]
[Search]
[Download]
[Bill]
[Help]
AUSTRALIAN CRIME COMMISSION (ACT) BILL 2003
2003
LEGISLATIVE
ASSEMBLY FOR THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL
TERRITORY
AUSTRALIAN CRIME COMMISSION (ACT) BILL 2003
EXPLANATORY
STATEMENT
Circulated by authority of the
Minister for
Police and Emergency Services
Mr Bill Wood MLA
AUSTRALIAN CRIME COMMISSION (ACT) BILL 2003
This explanatory statement relates to the Bill as introduced into the
ACT Legislative Assembly.
Overview of the Bill
The purpose of this Bill is to complement the Australian Crime
Commission Act 2002 (Cwlth) (the Commonwealth Act) to provide for the
operation of the Australian Crime Commission (ACC) in the Australian Capital
Territory (ACT).
The ACC, established under the Commonwealth Act, came into operation on
1 January 2003 replacing the National Crime Authority (NCA). The ACC
combines the investigative functions of the former NCA with the criminal
intelligence functions of the former Australian Bureau of Criminal Intelligence
and the former Office of Strategic Crime Assessments.
The Commonwealth
Act maintains the powers that were available to the former NCA and enables these
powers to be used for both the ACC's investigatory role and its new criminal
intelligence role. These powers are available in relation to intelligence
operations and investigations relating to relevant federal criminal activity.
In addition, the Commonwealth Act establishes the governance regime for the
ACC, including the establishment of a board and an office of Chief Executive
Officer (CEO) of the ACC.
The board is made up of Commonwealth, State
and Territory law enforcement representatives and is responsible under the
Commonwealth Act for determining national criminal intelligence priorities and
overseeing the strategic direction of the ACC, as well as authorising
intelligence operations, investigations and the use of special powers. The CEO
is responsible under the Commonwealth Act for managing the day-to-day
administration of the ACC and for coordinating ACC operations and
investigations.
The Commonwealth Act also establishes the
Inter-Governmental Committee (IGC) responsible for maintaining an appropriate
monitoring and oversight role in relation to the ACC.
Lastly, the
Commonwealth Act provides for the coercive examination powers that were
available to the former NCA to be exercised by examiners. These powers were
formerly exercised by members and hearing officers of the NCA.
The Bill
and comparable legislation in other States and Territories will enable the ACC
to undertake like functions to those under the Commonwealth Act in relation to
relevant criminal activity that relates to State or Territory offences,
irrespective of whether those offences have a federal aspect. This will ensure
that the ACC can operate as effectively and seamlessly as possible on a national
basis.
The Bill provides for the functions and powers of the ACC, the
board, and the CEO under ACT law. Similarly to the Commonwealth Act, the Bill
maintains the powers that were available to the former NCA and enables these
powers to be used for both the ACC's investigatory and criminal intelligence
roles.
The Bill creates offences for contraventions of the provisions to
facilitate the effective performance of the ACC's functions. These offences
reflect equivalent offences that are contained in the Commonwealth Act, however
it should be noted the offences have been drafted in accordance with the
requirements of the Criminal Code 2002 consistent with all new
ACT legislation. Penalties in the Bill reflect current penalty policy in the
ACT. Some penalties are higher than for the equivalent offence in the
Commonwealth Act.
The Bill will repeal the ACT’s NCA legislation,
the National Crime Authority (Territory Provisions) Act 1991. The Bill
contains transitional provisions to facilitate a seamless transition from the
NCA to the ACC under ACT law.
The Bill also contains consequential
amendments that are necessary because of the replacement of the NCA with the ACC
and the repeal of the National Crime Authority (Territory Provisions) Act
1991.
Outline of provisions
Part 1 Preliminary
Clause 1 Name of Act
This clause sets out the name of the
proposed Act as the Australian Crime Commission (ACT) Act
2003.
Clause 2 Commencement
This clause provides for the commencement of the Bill, apart from clauses 1
and 2, on a day to be fixed by the Minister via written notice. This is to
enable regulations and related Commonwealth amendments to be prepared to ensure
that certain duties, functions and powers invested by State and Territory laws
in the ACC, the ACC board and the IGC-ACC, are constitutionally valid. For
example, with respect to clause 18 (board committees) and division 2.3
(the IGC), the legislative consent provision in section 55A(4) of the
Commonwealth Act must be amended to extend to members of the board and the IGC,
to ensure the validity of these clauses. It is expected that the Commonwealth
will make the necessary amendments to its Act during the Spring 2003
Parliamentary sittings.
The provisions of the Bill will automatically commence 6 months after
its notification day if they have not been commenced by the Minister
earlier.
Clause 3 Dictionary
This clause states that the dictionary, at the end of the Bill, forms a
part of the Bill.
Clause 4 Notes
This clause makes it clear that notes in the Bill are explanatory only and
do not form part of the Bill.
Clause 5 Offences against Act – application
of Criminal Code etc
This clause is a standard provision stating that other legislation applies
for offences against this Bill. This section alerts the reader to the
application of Chapter 2 of the Criminal Code to all offence provisions.
Chapter 2 sets out the general principles of criminal responsibility and defines
relevant terms such as conduct, intention, recklessness and strict liability for
the purposes of the offence provisions.
Clause 6 Terms used in ACC Act
This clause provides for terms used in the Australian Crime Commission
Act 2002 (Cwlth) to have the same meaning in this Bill. In particular, the
term ‘State’, includes the Australian Capital Territory and the
Northern Territory. The word ‘Territory’ generally refers to the
external territories. The Legislation Act 2001, s.155 makes this subject
to a contrary intention in the Bill. For example, where a term is defined such
as “ACC Territory investigation” or “Territory
Minister”.
Clause 7 Incidental offences may be taken to be
serious and organised crime
"Serious and organised crime" is defined in the dictionary. This clause
extends the meaning of the term "serious and organised crime" to include
incidental offences, connected with a course of activity involving the
commission of a serious and organised crime.
Part 2 The ACC, the board and
intergovernmental committee
Division 2.1 Australian Crime Commission
Clause 8 Functions of
ACC
This clause sets out the functions of the ACC, complementing section 7A of
the Commonwealth Act. The investigatory function of the ACC is similar to the
investigatory function previously undertaken by the NCA. This provision will
enable the ACC to investigate relevant criminal activity where the board has
consented to the ACC doing so under the Commonwealth Act. The ACC will only be
empowered to investigate relevant criminal activity to the extent that it is, or
includes, an offence or offences against an ACT law.
Paragraph (b)
reflects the new role that the ACC has in relation to criminal intelligence,
providing for the ACC to undertake intelligence operations where the board has
consented to the ACC doing so under the Commonwealth Act. As with its
investigatory function, the ACC will only be empowered to undertake intelligence
operations in connection with offences against an ACT law.
The ACC must
provide reports to the board on the outcome of its investigations and
intelligence operations under paragraph (c). Paragraph (d) provides that the
ACC has such other functions as are conferred on it by other provisions of the
Bill or any other Act. For example, functions could be conferred on the ACC by
other ACT laws creating investigative powers, subject to the necessary
legislative consent under section 55A of the Commonwealth
Act.
Clause 9 CEO to manage ACC
operations/investigations
This clause provides that the CEO's functions are to coordinate ACC
operations and investigations, determine the head of an ACC operation or
investigation and arrange for an examiner who is to be able to exercise his or
her powers under the Bill in relation to a special ACC operation/investigation.
This provision complements a similar provision contained in section 46A of the
Commonwealth Act. It should be noted that under section 46A of the Commonwealth
Act, the CEO is also responsible for the day-to-day administration of the
ACC.
Clause 10 Counsel assisting ACC
This clause enables the CEO to appoint a legal practitioner to assist the
ACC. This complements an equivalent provision in section 50 of the Commonwealth
Act.
Division 2.2 Board of
ACC
Clause 11 Functions of board
This clause sets out the functions of the board and complements section 7A
of the Commonwealth Act, which provides for the functions of the ACC. This
clause should be read together with section 55A(3) of the Commonwealth Act,
which requires board consent under that Act for the ACC to undertake an ACC
State intelligence operation or ACC State investigation. The ACT is included in
the definition of a State for the Commonwealth Act.
The board has the
function of determining whether an ACC operation or investigation is a special
operation or investigation. This determination then allows for the exercise of
coercive powers under the Bill.
The board may also determine the classes
of persons to participate in an ACC Territory intelligence
operation/investigation. For example, the board may determine that members of a
State or Territory police force that are seconded to the ACC are to participate
in a particular ACC Territory intelligence operation/investigation. The board
can establish task forces to conduct an ACC Territory intelligence
operation/investigation and exercise any other functions conferred on it by
other provisions of the Bill.
Determinations made by the board must be
contained in a written determination of the board authorising the use of special
powers. It must describe the general nature of the circumstances or allegations
constituting the relevant criminal activity; state what the serious and
organised crime is or that the serious and organised crimes are or include an
offence or offences against an ACT law and set out the purpose of the operation
or investigation. However, before determining that an investigation is a
special investigation or that an operation is a special operation, the board
must first consider whether ordinary methods of collection of criminal
information and intelligence, or police methods of investigation into the
matters have been effective, or are likely to be effective. These provisions
provide an important safeguard in setting out the parameters for the
board’s authorisation of the use of special powers under the
Bill.
Clause 11(7) requires the chair of the board to provide to the
inter-governmental committee (IGC), a copy of a determination authorising the
use of special powers within 3 days of the determination being made. This will
facilitate the IGC's oversight function under clause 19.
Subclause (9)
provides that clauses 12 to 18 relating to board meetings have effect in
relation to the board's functions under the Bill.
Clause 12 Board meetings
This clause sets out the requirements for board meetings. The chair must
ensure that board meetings are convened in accordance with the complementary
provisions governing board meetings in section 7D of the Commonwealth
Act.
Clause 13 Presiding at board meetings
This clause provides that the chair of the board or another eligible
Commonwealth board member nominated by the chair must preside at a board
meeting. An eligible Commonwealth board member is defined in the Commonwealth
Act to mean, in effect, another Commonwealth member of the board, other than the
CEO.
Clause 14 Quorum at board meetings
This clause provides that a quorum of the board is seven members, excluding
the CEO.
Clause 15 Voting at board meetings
This clause sets out the voting procedures to apply at board meetings.
Generally, a simple majority vote will determine decisions of the board.
However, special voting requirements apply to board determinations authorising
the use of special powers, as an additional safeguard on the exercise of these
powers. The board can only determine that a Territory ACC operation or
investigation is a special operation or investigation if at least nine board
members agree, including at least two eligible Commonwealth board members.
The CEO has no voting rights.
Clause 16 Conduct of board meetings
This clause provides that the board may regulate proceedings at its
meetings as it considers appropriate and requires minutes of board meetings to
be kept.
Clause 17 Resolutions outside of board
meetings
This clause allows decisions of the board to be taken by resolution out of
session, enabling the board to make decisions without a formal meeting being
held. The special voting requirements that apply to a determination of the board
authorising the use of special powers will continue to apply to any such
determination that is made out of session.
Clause 18 Board
committees
This clause enables the board to establish committees to
assist in carrying out its functions, recognising the need for the board to
operate by committee when appropriate. However, limitations are imposed on the
establishment and functions of committees to ensure sufficient accountability in
relation to the exercise of board functions by committees. The most important
limitation is that the board’s function of determining whether an ACC
Territory intelligence operation or an ACC Territory investigation is a special
operation or investigation, cannot be exercised by a committee. The full board
must exercise this function. A committee must let other board members know of
its decisions and ensure that minutes of its meetings are kept.
Division 2.3 Inter-governmental committee
Clause 19 Functions of committee
This clause provides for the
functions of the IGC in relation to the revocation of special determinations
made by the board, and complementary powers for the IGC to obtain further
information about a special determination from the chair of the board. These
provisions complement section 9 of the Commonwealth Act which provides more
generally for the oversight and monitoring role of the IGC in relation to the
ACC and the board.
Subclauses (1) to (5) set out the procedures for the
IGC to obtain further information from the chair of the board in relation to
a board determination authorising the use of special powers. The chair
of the board must not provide information requested by the IGC if the public
disclosure of the information could prejudice a person's safety or reputation or
the operations of law enforcement agencies. If the chair of the board decides on
this ground not to provide the information sought, the IGC can refer the request
to the Territory Minister, who must determine whether disclosure of the
information could prejudice a person's safety or reputation or the
operations of law enforcement agencies. This mechanism for referral of the
matter to the Territory Minister provides an additional check on the
provision to the IGC of information that it may require in determining whether
to revoke a special determination under subclause (6).
Subclause (6)
provides for the IGC to revoke by resolution a special determination made by the
board. The resolution can be made with the agreement of the Commonwealth member
of the IGC and at least five other members of the IGC. The IGC's power to revoke
a special determination is a further safeguard on the exercise of the special
powers under the Bill. The IGC is required to notify the chair of the board and
the CEO if it revokes a special determination. The revocation takes effect
when the CEO is notified.
Part 3
Examinations
Clause 20
Examinations
This clause provides that an examiner may conduct an examination for the
purposes of a special ACC operation/investigation. The power to conduct
examinations, including coercive powers to produce documents and answer
questions, is a powerful investigative tool central to the role and functions of
the ACC.
Clause 21 Conduct of examination
This clause regulates the conduct of examinations, complementing an
equivalent provision in section 25A of the Commonwealth Act. Subclause (1)
provides that an examiner may conduct the proceedings in the manner he or she
thinks appropriate.
Examiners are independent statutory officers
appointed by the Governor-General under the Commonwealth Act. An examiner must
be employed on a full-time basis and have been enrolled as a legal practitioner
for at least five years. While clause 9(4) enables the CEO to allocate an
examiner to a particular special ACC operation/investigation, this does not
fetter the statutory discretion of the examiner in exercising his or her powers.
The independence of examiners is an important safeguard on the exercise of the
special powers under the Bill.
Subclause (2) provides for legal
representation of witnesses and, in some circumstances, with the
examiner’s consent, non-witnesses.
Subclause (3) requires an
examination to be held in private and empowers the examiner to give directions
regarding the presence of persons during an examination.
Subclause (4)
then makes it clear that such a direction does not prevent the presence of the
legal representative of a witness, or non-witness if the examiner has consented
to his or her presence.
Subclause (5) precludes the presence of a person
(other than approved ACC staff members) at an examination unless the examiner
has given a direction under subclause (3) permitting the person to be
present, or if subclause (4) applies.
Subclause (6) makes it an offence
for a person to be present at an examination knowing that he or she is not
entitled to be present. The maximum penalty is 100 penalty units, one
year’s imprisonment or both.
Subclause (7) provides for the
examination and cross-examination of witnesses by counsel assisting the
examiner, someone authorised by the examiner to appear or any legal practitioner
representing persons present under subclause (2).
Subclause (8) requires
an examiner to inform a witness of the presence of a non-witness at an
examination and allow the witness to comment on that person's presence.
Subclause (9) makes it clear that a non-witness does not cease to be
entitled to be present at an examination if the examiner fails to comply with
subclause (8) or a witness comments adversely on the presence of a non-witness.
For example, if the ACC is coordinating its activities, in accordance with
clause 40(2), with the functions of an overseas authority that performs similar
functions to the ACC and a representative of that authority is present at an
examination, the examiner must inform a witness of that person's presence.
Subclause (10) enables an examiner to make a non-publication direction
prohibiting the publication of:
• evidence given at an examination or
documents or things produced to the examiner;
• information that might
enable a witness to be identified; or
• the fact that a person has or
may give evidence at an examination.
This provision would enable an examiner to make a non-publication direction
if, for example, the publication of matters relating to the conduct of an
examination might compromise the effectiveness of an ACC operation or
investigation. An examiner must make a non-publication direction if the failure
to do so might prejudice the safety or reputation of a person or the fair trial
of a person who has been or may be charged with an offence (subclause (11)).
Subclauses (12) and (13) provide for the CEO to revoke a non-publication
direction made by an examiner under subclause (10). This power is consistent
with the CEO's functions of managing, regulating and controlling ACC operations
and investigations under clause 9(1).
Subclause (14) sets out a procedure under which a court can require
evidence given before an examiner that is subject to a non-publication direction
under subclause (10) to be made available to the court. A court can require
evidence to be made available if a person has been charged with an offence and
the court considers that it may be desirable in the interests of justice that
evidence given before an examiner be made available to that person or his or her
legal practitioner. Once the evidence has been made available to the court,
subclause (15) enables the court to make that evidence available to the charged
person or his or her legal practitioner.
Subclause (16) makes it an offence if an examiner makes a non-publication
direction under subsection (10) and a person publishes something in
contravention of the direction and is reckless about whether the publication
contravenes the direction. The maximum penalty is 100 penalty units, one
year’s imprisonment or both.
Subclause (17) requires an examiner to give the head of the special ACC
operation/investigation at the conclusion of an examination a record of
proceedings of the examination and any documents or things given to the
examiner.
Clause 22 Power to summon witnesses and take
evidence
This clause provides for an examiner's powers to summon witnesses and take
evidence, enabling an examiner to summon a person to appear before him or her to
give evidence and to produce documents or things. The examiner must be satisfied
it is reasonable to do so and must record his or her reasons for issuing the
summons.
Subclause (4) requires a summons to be accompanied by a copy of
the determination of the board that the ACC Territory intelligence operation or
investigation is a special operation/investigation. The summons must set out the
general nature of the matters in relation to which the examiner intends to
question the person, unless this would prejudice the effectiveness of the
special ACC operation/investigation (subclause (5).
Subclauses (6) and
(7) empower an examiner to require a person appearing at an examination to
produce a document or thing and take evidence on oath or affirmation. Subclause
(8) provides for a person who is authorised by the CEO to be present in an
examination to administer the oath or affirmation.
Subclause (9) makes
it clear that the powers to summon witnesses and take evidence under this clause
can only be exercised in relation to a special ACC operation or investigation,
subjecting this clause to the safeguards that apply under the Bill relating to
the authorisation of the use of special powers.
Clause 23 Power to obtain documents
This clause provides for an examiner's power to obtain documents, enabling
an examiner, by written notice, to require a person to attend before the
examiner or a member of staff of the ACC to produce specified documents or
things relevant to a special ACC operation/investigation. The examiner must be
satisfied it is reasonable to do so and must record his or her reasons for
issuing the notice.
Subclause (4) makes it clear that a notice may be
issued in relation to a special ACC operation/investigation regardless of
whether an examination before an examiner is being held. Under subclause (5) a
person, who is served with a notice, must not intentionally fail to attend an
examination or fail to produce documents or things as stated. This is an
indictable offence with a maximum penalty of 500 penalty units, imprisonment for
5 years or both. However, this offence may be dealt with summarily under the
provisions of section 375 of the Crimes Act 1900 in certain
circumstances. In this case, the maximum penalty that can be imposed by the
court is $5000 or two years imprisonment.
Subclause (6) applies the same
provisions in clauses 26(4) and (5) [which allows a legal practitioner to refuse
to provide information to an examiner on the ground of legal professional
privilege, subject to a requirement that the legal practitioner identifies the
person to whom the privilege applies], clauses 26(6), (7) and (8) [which deal
with self-incrimination] and clause 26(9) [which makes it clear that clause
26(4) does not affect the law relating to legal professional privilege] that
apply to a person who is required to produce a document or thing at an
examination to the production of documents or things pursuant to a notice under
this clause.
Clause 24 Disclosure of summons or notice may be
prohibited
This clause provides for the inclusion of a non-disclosure notation in a
summons or notice issued under clause 22 or 23 to prohibit the disclosure of
information about the summons or notice or any official matter connected with
it. Subclause (2) sets out the circumstances in which an examiner may, or must,
include a non-disclosure notation in a summons or notice. A notation must be
included if the examiner is satisfied that failing to do so would reasonably be
expected to prejudice a person's safety or reputation, the fair trial of a
person or the effectiveness of an ACC operation or investigation. A notation may
be included if the examiner is satisfied that failing to do so might prejudice a
person's safety or reputation, the fair trial of a person or the effectiveness
of an ACC operation or investigation. An examiner may also include a notation if
he or she is satisfied that the failure to do so might otherwise be contrary to
the public interest.
Subclause (3) requires a written statement setting
out a person's rights and obligations under clause 25 to accompany the notation.
Clause 25 creates offences for the contravention of a notation.
Subclause (4) provides for the automatic cancellation of a notation in
certain circumstances where it is no longer necessary to prevent disclosure of
information about a summons or notice. The CEO is required to serve written
notice of the cancellation of a notation to each person who received the summons
or notice containing the notation.
Clause 25 Offences of disclosure
This clause creates offences for disclosing certain information about a
summons or notice that contains a non-disclosure notation under clause 24.
Subclause (1) makes it an offence for a person who receives a summons or notice
containing such a non-disclosure notation, to disclose the existence of, or
information about the summons or notice or official matters connected with the
summons or notice, reckless about whether it will make a disclosure of this
kind. The maximum penalty is 100 penalty units, one year’s imprisonment or
both.
Subclause (2) sets out exceptions to subclause (1) where
disclosure is permitted, recognising there will be circumstances in which it is
necessary and appropriate to disclose information about a summons or notice. A
person who receives a summons or notice containing a non-disclosure notation can
disclose the existence of, or information about the summons or notice or an
official matter connected with it -
• in accordance with any
circumstances specified in the notation;
• to a legal practitioner for
the purposes of obtaining legal advice or representation;
• if the
person is a body corporate, to an officer or agent of the body corporate to
ensure compliance with the summons or notice; or
• if the person is a
legal practitioner, for the purposes of obtaining the consent of another
person under clause 26(4) to the legal practitioner answering a question or
producing a document before an examiner. Clause 26(4) will apply where a legal
practitioner is required to answer a question or produce a document that would
disclose communications protected by legal professional privilege, and he or she
seeks the agreement of the person to whom the privilege applies to answer the
question or produce the document.
Subclause (3) makes it an offence if a
person receives information about a summons or notice in accordance with
subclause (2) or (4) and while the person is a person to whom a disclosure is
allowed to be made, the person discloses the existence of, or information about
the summons or notice or official matters connected with the summons or notice
and is reckless about whether the later communication will make a disclosure of
this kind. The maximum penalty is 100 penalty units, one year’s
imprisonment or both.
Subclause (4) sets out the circumstances in which
that person can disclose the information. These are:
• if the person is
an officer or agent of the body corporate that received the summons or notice,
he or she may disclose the information to another officer or agent to ensure
compliance with the summons or notice or to a legal practitioner for the
purposes of obtaining legal advice or representation; or
• if the
person is a legal practitioner, he or she may disclose the information for the
purposes of providing advice or representation.
Subclause (5) makes it
an offence for a person who receives information about a summons or notice in
the circumstances set out in subclause (2) or (4) to make a record of, or
disclose the existence of, or information about the summons, notice or official
matters connected with the summons or notice, reckless about whether the later
disclosure is a disclosure of this kind, after the person is no longer a person
to whom such a disclosure may be made. For example, a legal practitioner who
receives information about a summons or notice for the purposes of providing
legal advice or representation cannot disclose this information if he or she
ceases to be a legal practitioner. The maximum penalty is 100 penalty units, one
year’s imprisonment or both.
Subclause (6) provides that the
disclosure offences in this clause will cease to apply when the notation
contained in the summons or notice is automatically cancelled under clause
24(4), or five years after the summons or notice has been issued, whichever is
sooner. This recognises that once 5 years have elapsed after the issue of a
summons or notice, the interests affected by the contravention of a
non-disclosure notation in the summons or notice will no longer be such as to
warrant criminal punishment.
Clause 26 Failure of witnesses to attend and answer
questions
Clause 26 provides for offences for failure to attend and answer questions
at an examination and deals with self-incrimination and use immunity.
Subclause (1) provides that a person must not intentionally fail to attend
an examination as required by a summons, or fail to attend from day to day. The
maximum penalty is 500 penalty units, 5 year’s imprisonment or both. This
offence may be dealt with summarily under the provisions of section 375 of the
Crimes Act 1900 in certain circumstances. In this case, the maximum
penalty that can be imposed by the court is $5000 or 2 years
imprisonment.
Subclause (2) provides that if a person does not attend from day to day, an
offence is not committed if the examiner has excused or released the person from
attending on a day or part of a day.
Subclause (3) provides that a witness at an examination must not
intentionally fail to take an oath or affirmation, answer a question required by
the examiner, or produce a document or thing in answer to a summons. The maximum
penalty is 500 penalty units, 5 year’s imprisonment or both. This
offence may be dealt with summarily under the provisions of section 375 of the
Crimes Act 1900 in certain circumstances. In this case, the maximum
penalty that can be imposed by the court is $5000 or two years
imprisonment.
Subclause (4) enables a legal practitioner to refuse to answer questions or
produce documents at an examination on the ground of legal professional
privilege. Subclause (5) makes it an offence if the legal
practitioner refuses to comply with the requirement under subclause (4) and
intentionally fails to provide the name and address of the person to whom the
privilege applies if required to do so by the examiner. The maximum penalty is
500 penalty units, five year’s imprisonment or both. This offence
may be dealt with summarily under the provisions of section 375 of the
Crimes Act 1900 in certain circumstances. In this case, the
maximum penalty that can be imposed by the court is $5000 or two years
imprisonment
Subclauses (6), (7) and (8) set out provisions dealing with
self-incrimination and use immunity in relation to evidence given at an
examination.
Subclause (7) sets out the circumstances in which a person may claim the
privilege against self-incrimination. A person can claim the privilege if--
• before answering a question that the person is required to answer at
an examination;
• before producing, in answer to a summons, a business
document that sets out details of earnings received by the person in respect of
his or her employment and does not set out any other information; or
• before producing a thing in answer to a summons--
the person claims that the answer, document or thing might tend to
incriminate the person or make the person liable to a penalty.
Subclause (8) limits the use that can be made of certain evidence if one of
the situations in subclause (7) exists. If one of these situations exists, the
answer, document or thing cannot be used as evidence against the person, except
in confiscation proceedings or proceedings in relation to the falsity of
evidence given by the person. However, any evidence that is derived from the
answer, document or thing may be used against the person.
Subclause (9) clarifies that subclause (4) does not affect the law relating
to legal professional privilege. So, where a legal practitioner is required to
provide certain information to an examiner and to do so would disclose
privileged information, the legal practitioner may refuse to produce that
information, unless the person to whom the privilege applies consents to its
disclosure.
Clause 27 Warrant for arrest of witness
Clause 27 empowers a Judge of the Federal Court or the Supreme Court to
issue a warrant for the arrest of a person in specified circumstances upon an
application made by an examiner. This is an important power to ensure that the
investigatory process of the ACC is not thwarted. As the coercive examination
powers under the Bill are only available in connection with a special ACC
operation/investigation, the power to arrest and detain a person to ensure his
or her appearance before an examiner will be subject to the safeguards that
apply under the Bill in relation to the authorisation of the use of special
powers.
Subclause (1) sets out the grounds for issue of such a warrant. The Judge
must be satisfied by evidence on oath that there are reasonable grounds to
believe that--
(a) a person who has been ordered to surrender his or her passport under
clause 31 is nevertheless likely to leave Australia to avoid giving evidence
before an examiner;
(b) a person is attempting or is likely to attempt to evade service of a
summons to appear at an examination that has been issued under clause 22(1); or
(c) a person has committed an offence under clause 26(1) by failing to
attend an examination in answer to a summons.
Subclause (2) enables a warrant to be executed by any person to whom it is
addressed. The person executing the warrant is empowered to break and enter any
premises, vessel, aircraft or vehicle to execute it. Subclause (3) provides
that the warrant may be executed even if the person executing it doesn’t
have the warrant in their possession at the time. Subclause (4) makes it clear
that reasonable force can be used in the execution of a warrant.
Subclause (5) sets out the procedure for dealing with a person who is
apprehended under a warrant. He or she must be brought as soon as practicable
before a Judge of the Federal Court or the Supreme Court and the Judge or Court
may admit the person to bail, order the continued detention of the person to
ensure his or her appearance as a witness before an examiner or order the
release of the person.
Subclause (6) requires a person who is detained under clause 27 to be
brought back before a Judge of the Federal Court or the Supreme Court within 14
days, or any other period fixed by the Judge or Court. The Judge or Court is
then empowered to exercise any of the powers under subclause (5) in relation to
the person.
Clause 28 False or misleading evidence
Clause 28 makes it an indictable offence to knowingly give false or
misleading evidence at an examination before an examiner. The maximum penalty is
500 penalty units or 5 years' imprisonment or both. This offence may be
dealt with summarily under the provisions of section 375 of the Crimes Act
1900 in certain circumstances. In this case, the maximum penalty that can
be imposed by the court is $5000 or two years imprisonment.
Clause 29 Protection of witnesses from harm or
intimidation
Clause 29 allows an examiner to make arrangements to protect a person who
is appearing or has appeared at an examination before an examiner or proposes to
give, or has given, information or other documents other than at an examination.
An examiner can make arrangements, including with the Territory Minister or with
members of the police force, to ensure that the safety of a person is not
prejudiced or a person is not subject to intimidation or harassment.
Clause 30 Legal protection of examiners, counsel and
witnesses
Clause 30 provides, in relation to an examination before an examiner, the
same legal protection and immunity for examiners, witnesses and legal
practitioners assisting the ACC or an examiner or representing a witness, as
would apply in proceedings in the High Court. This ensures that the conduct of
an examination is not constrained by a risk of tortious liability that may
otherwise arise from things said or done in the conduct of an examination.
Clause 31 Order for giving passport of witness to
examiner
Clause 31 enables an examiner to apply to a Judge of the Federal Court for
an order that a person who has been summonsed in connection with a special ACC
operation/investigation to appear before the examiner, or who has appeared
before the examiner, must surrender his or her passport to the examiner.
There must be reasonable grounds for believing that the person may be able
to provide evidence, documents or things, or further evidence, documents or
things that could be of particular significance to the special
operation/investigation. In addition, an order may only be made where there are
reasonable grounds for suspecting that the person intends to leave Australia.
An order can authorise an examiner to retain a person's passport for a
specified period of up to one month. This period can be extended, upon
application, for a further period of up to one month, up to a maximum total
period of three months.
As an order for the delivery of a passport can only
be made in connection with a special ACC operation/ investigation, this power
will be subject to the safeguards that apply under the Bill in relation to the
authorisation of the use of special powers.
Part 4
Search warrants
Clause 32 Search warrants
Clause 32 enables an eligible person to apply to an issuing officer for a
search warrant. An eligible person is defined under section 4(1) of the
Commonwealth Act to mean an examiner or a member of staff of the ACC who is also
a member of the Australian Federal Police or a State police force. State
includes the Australian Capital Territory and the Northern Territory under the
Commonwealth Act. An issuing officer is defined in the dictionary to mean a
judge of the Federal Court, or a judge of the Supreme Court or a federal
magistrate.
Subclause (1) provides that an eligible person can apply
for a search warrant if he or she has reasonable grounds to suspect that there
may be in any premises or other specified place a thing of a particular kind
connected with a special ACC operation/investigation which he or she believes on
reasonable grounds might be concealed, lost, mutilated or destroyed if a summons
for the production of the thing were issued. This means that a search warrant
application can only be made in circumstances where the power to issue a summons
for the production of a thing would be effective to secure the production of the
thing in question.
Subclause (2) sets out the things that a search
warrant may allow an authorised person to do. An authorised person can enter and
search the premises or other specified place and seize any things of the
relevant kind, and deliver them to any person participating in the special ACC
operation/investigation. An authorised person can use force, if necessary, to
execute the warrant.
Subclause (3) sets outs conditions for the issue of
a warrant. An affidavit must have been provided setting out the grounds on which
the warrant is sought, the applicant must have provided any further information
required by the issuing officer as to why the warrant is sought, and the issuing
officer must be satisfied that there are reasonable grounds for issuing the
warrant. Under subclause (4) the issuing officer is required to state the
grounds on which a warrant has been issued.
Subclause (5) specifies that
the warrant must contain the following details:
• state the purpose of
the warrant, including a reference to the relevant special ACC
operation/investigation with which the things the subject of the warrant are
connected;
• state when entry can be made under the warrant;
• describe the kind of things that can be seized; and
• specify when the warrant ceases to have effect. The maximum
period for which a warrant can be valid is one month. Under subclause (5) a
warrant may be executed at any time during this period.
Subclause (7)
makes it clear that only the necessary reasonable force can be used in the
execution of a warrant. Subclause (8) provides that evidence that is found in
the course of searching for things of the relevant kind under a warrant may be
seized. Such evidence can only be seized, however, if the person executing the
warrant reasonably believes that the seizure is necessary to prevent its
concealment, loss, mutilation or destruction or to prevent the evidence being
used to commit an offence.
Subclauses (9) and (10) provide for the
retention and delivery of things seized under warrant. Subclause (9) enables the
head of a special ACC operation/investigation to retain a thing seized under
warrant for as long as is reasonably necessary for the purposes of the relevant
special ACC operation/investigation. If it is not, or ceases to be,
reasonably necessary to retain a thing for such a purpose, the thing must be
delivered:
• if it may be admissible evidence in proceedings by the
Commonwealth, a State or a Territory for a civil remedy, to the relevant person
or authority responsible for taking the proceedings; or
• otherwise,
to the person who appears to be entitled to the possession of the thing.
These obligations do not apply if the CEO has already given the thing to the
relevant Commonwealth, or State Attorney General or to a law enforcement agency
or prosecuting authority in accordance with clause 37(1)(a), (b) or (c). That
clause requires the CEO to assemble evidence that would be admissible in the
prosecution of an offence and give it to the relevant Commonwealth, or State
Attorney General, a law enforcement agency or prosecuting authority.
Rather than delivering a thing seized under warrant to the person who
appears to be entitled to it in accordance with subclause (9), subclause (10)
enables a participant in a special ACC operation/investigation to deliver the
thing to the relevant Commonwealth or State Attorney General or to a law
enforcement agency if it is likely to assist in the investigation of a criminal
offence.
Subclause (11) makes it clear that clause 32 does not affect
other rights to apply for a warrant or other powers to issue a warrant. For
example, clause 32 would not prevent an eligible person such as a member of
staff of the ACC who is also a police officer from applying under other ACT laws
for a warrant in connection with an offence that is the subject of an ACC
Territory investigation.
Clause 33 Application by telephone for search
warrants
This clause allows an eligible person to apply for a search warrant by
telephone where a warrant is required urgently.
For an application by
telephone the eligible person must first prepare an affidavit setting out the
grounds on which the warrant is sought. However, if necessary, the application
may be made before the affidavit has been sworn.
Subclause (3) requires
an issuing officer who issues a search warrant by telephone to inform the
applicant of the terms of the warrant and the date and time it was issued and
record the reasons it was issued on the warrant. A copy of the warrant is
required to be forwarded to the CEO.
Subclause (4) provides that a
member of the staff of the ACC or a police officer may complete a form of
warrant in the terms indicated by the issuing officer. The member or officer
must record on it the issuing officer's name and the date and time of issuing.
The completed form of the warrant together with the eligible person’s
sworn affidavit must be sent to the issuing officer no later than the day after
the warrant expires. Upon receipt of the documents, the issuing officer must
attach them to the warrant signed by him or herself and deal with them, as they
would have done under clause 32. A form of warrant duly completed under
subsection (4) is to be taken to be a warrant issued under section
32.
Part 5 Exercising
functions
Clause 34 Consent of board may be needed before functions can be
exercised
This clause provides that the conferral of functions on a
Commonwealth body or person is subject to the consent of the board under the
Commonwealth Act. This provision complements section 55A(5A) of the Commonwealth
Act, which provides that the CEO or an examiner cannot perform a duty or
function or exercise a power under State (includes the ACT) law relating to the
investigation of a relevant criminal activity or the undertaking of an
intelligence operation unless the board has consented to the ACC doing so.
Clause 35 Functions not affected by Territory
laws
This clause makes it clear, to avoid doubt, that a Commonwealth body or
person is not precluded by any ACT law from performing functions under the Act.
Clause 36 Extent to which functions are
given
This clause provides that the Bill does not purport to impose any duty on
a Commonwealth body or person to perform a function if the imposition
would be beyond Territory legislative power. Subclause (2) then provides that
the general interpretative provision contained in section 120 of the
Legislation Act 2001, providing that Acts should be read so as not to
exceed legislative power but to operate to the full extent of the power of the
Legislative Assembly, is not limited by the section. These provisions are
intended to ensure that the Bill does not contravene any constitutional doctrine
that restricts the duties that may be imposed on Commonwealth bodies or persons.
This clause also does not limit clause 38, which makes it clear that a function
conferred on a federal judicial officer under the Bill is conferred on him or
her in a personal capacity.
Clause 37 Exercising functions
This clause imposes obligations on the CEO in relation to what he or she
must do with information obtained by the ACC. Where admissible evidence is
obtained during the course of an ACC operation/investigation, the CEO must
assemble the evidence and give it to the relevant Commonwealth, or State
Attorney General, law enforcement agency or prosecuting authority. This
obligation applies under subclause (1) in relation to evidence that would
be admissible in the prosecution of an offence and under subclause (2) in
relation to evidence that would be admissible in confiscation
proceedings.
This clause also allows, at subclause (3), for the board to
make law reform or administrative reform recommendations to the Commonwealth
Minister or the appropriate State Minister.
Subclause (4) provides that
where the ACC obtains information or intelligence in the course of performing
one of its functions, that information or intelligence may be used for the
purposes of other ACC functions. For example, information obtained during an
intelligence operation may be used during an investigation into relevant
criminal activity. This provision recognises the integrated nature of the ACC's
intelligence and investigatory functions and ensures that the use of information
by the ACC is not artificially restricted.
Clause 38 Functions of federal judicial
officers
This clause makes it clear that a function conferred by the Bill on a
federal judicial officer (a judge of the Federal Court or a federal magistrate)
is conferred on that person in a personal capacity and not as a court or member
of a court, and the federal judicial officer need not accept the function
conferred. This provision is intended to ensure that the Bill does not breach
any constitutional doctrine that restricts the duties that may be conferred on
federal judicial officers by the ACT. If the judicial officer exercises a
function under this Bill, the officer has the same protection as a member of the
court of which he or she is a member.
Clause 39 Limitation on challenge to board
determination
This clause limits, in certain circumstances, the challenges that may be
made in relation to activities of the ACC. Where the board has determined that
an ACC Territory intelligence operation/investigation is a special
operation/investigation, then an act or thing done by the ACC because of that
determination cannot be challenged in any ACT court on the ground that the
determination was not lawfully made. This prevents a court from looking behind
a determination to see if it was properly made. For example, it prevents a
challenge being made on the basis that there was an error in the procedure that
led to the determination being made.
This provision does not prevent
challenges in relation to the activities of the ACC once a determination is in
place. Also, this limitation does not apply to proceedings initiated by a
Commonwealth, or State Attorney General.
Clause 40 Cooperation with
law enforcement agencies and coordination with overseas authorities
This
clause makes it clear that the ACC must cooperate with other law enforcement
agencies, so far as practicable, in performing its functions under the Bill.
The ACC may also coordinate its activities with the functions of overseas
authorities that perform similar functions to those of the ACC.
Clause 41 Incidental powers of ACC
This clause empowers the ACC to do all things necessary in connection with,
or reasonably incidental to, the performance of its functions under the Bill.
Part 6 General
Clause 42 Arrangements for board to obtain information or
intelligence
This clause allows the Territory Minister to enter into
arrangements with the Commonwealth Minister, for the board to receive from the
ACT or an ACT authority, information and intelligence about criminal activities.
This provision allows Ministerial level arrangements to be made in relation to
the provision of ACT information or intelligence to the board. It is not
intended to affect the provision of information or intelligence from the ACT to
the board by other means, such as directly from the police to the board.
Clause 43 Administrative arrangements with
Commonwealth
This clause enables the Territory Minister to make an arrangement with the
Commonwealth for the provision of human resources by the ACT to perform services
for the ACC.
Clause 44 Judges to exercise functions under the ACC
Act
This clause makes it clear that a judge of the Supreme Court may exercise
functions conferred on him or her by section 22, 23 or 31 of the Commonwealth
Act. Section 22 of the Commonwealth Act empowers an issuing officer, which
includes in effect a Judge of the Supreme Court, to issue a search warrant and
section 23 of the Commonwealth Act enables such a warrant to be issued upon a
telephone application. The powers contained in sections 22 and 23 of the
Commonwealth Act are equivalent to those contained in clauses 32 and 33,
respectively, of the Bill. Section 31 of the Commonwealth Act empowers a
Judge the Supreme Court to issue a warrant for the arrest of a witness,
similarly to the power contained in clause 27.
Clause 45 Giving reports and information
This clause deals with the provision of reports and information about
the performance of the ACC's functions to relevant persons.
The chair of the board must keep the Commonwealth Minister informed of the
general conduct of the ACC in the performance of its functions under the Bill.
This recognises the role of the Commonwealth Minister in monitoring the general
conduct of the ACC, as a Commonwealth body established by Commonwealth
legislation.
The Commonwealth Minister may also request from the chair of the board
information concerning a specific matter relating to the performance by the ACC
of its functions under the Bill.
A State Minister (includes an ACT Minister) who is a member of the IGC may
also request from the chair of the board information concerning a specific
matter relating to the performance by the ACC of its functions under the Bill.
This enables the Minister to obtain information independently about the conduct
of the ACC functions as the Minister responsible for the administration of the
Act.
The chair of the board must comply with the request unless the chair
considers that disclosure of information to the public could prejudice the
safety or reputation of a person or the operations of law enforcement agencies.
The IGC may request the chair of the board to--
(a) provide information to the IGC concerning a specific matter relating to
an ACC operation/investigation that the ACC has or is conducting; and
(b) inform the IGC about the general conduct of the ACC in the performance
of its functions under the Bill.
The chair of the board must comply with such a request from the IGC,
subject to a requirement that the chair must not furnish a matter the disclosure
of which to members of the public could prejudice the safety or reputation of a
person or the operations of law enforcement agencies.
In addition to the IGC's power to request information from the chair of the
board, the chair of the board--
(a) may inform the IGC at such times as he or she considers appropriate
about the general conduct of the ACC in the exercise of its functions under the
Bill; and
(b) must provide to the IGC a report on the findings of any special ACC
operation/investigation conducted by the ACC for transmission to the governments
represented on the IGC--
subject to a requirement that the chair must not furnish a matter the
disclosure of which to members of the public could prejudice the safety or
reputation of a person or the operations of law enforcement agencies. Any such
matter must be included in a separate report prepared by the chair of the board
and given to the Territory Minister.
These provisions are intended to facilitate the role of the IGC in
monitoring generally the work of the ACC.
Clause 45(8) provides for inclusion in a report made by the ACC a
recommendation that the report be presented to the Legislative
Assembly.
Clause 45(9) enables the CEO to disseminate any relevant information that
is in the ACC's possession to another law enforcement agency, foreign law
enforcement agency or prescribed government authority. The CEO can only
disseminate such information if it appears to him or her to be appropriate to do
so, and the dissemination would not be contrary to a Commonwealth, State or
Territory law that would otherwise apply.
The CEO is also empowered to provide, in specified circumstances, any
information that is in the ACC's possession to:
• authorities
responsible for taking civil remedies on behalf of the Commonwealth, a State or
a Territory, where the information may be relevant for the purposes of taking
such remedies in connection with Commonwealth, State or Territory offences; and
• a Commonwealth, State or Territory authority or Administration,
where the information relates to the performance of the authority or
Administration; and
• the Australian Security Intelligence
Organisation, where the information is relevant to security as defined in
section 4 of the Commonwealth Australian Security Intelligence Organisation
Act 1979.
Clause 45(12) sets out a general prohibition on a report under the Bill
being made available to the public if it--
• contains a finding that
an offence has been committed; or
• makes a recommendation for the
prosecution of an offence--
unless the finding or recommendation indicates that it is based on evidence
that would be admissible in the prosecution of a person for that offence. This
provision is intended to ensure that the publication of a report containing
these matters does not compromise the fair trial or reputation of a person.
Clause 46 Secrecy
This clause imposes secrecy obligations on specified ACC officers. These
officers are the CEO, a member of the board, a member of staff of the ACC and an
examiner and those who have been such officers. These obligations are intended
to ensure that information that could jeopardise the effective conduct of the
ACC's functions is not improperly disclosed.
Clause 46(2) make it an offence for the CEO, a member of the board, a
member of the staff of the ACC and an examiner to make a record of any
information obtained in the course of their duties. It is also an offence to
publish or otherwise communicate this information reckless about whether such a
publication or communication would divulge restricted information to anyone.
Subclause (3) provides that it is not an offence where the making of the record,
or divulging of information was for the purposes of, or in connection with the
performance of his or her functions under, a relevant Act. This offence applies
to conduct either while a person is a specified ACC officer or after he or she
ceases to be such an officer. The maximum penalty for the offence is $100
penalty units, one year's imprisonment or both.
Clause 46(4) ensures that a specified ACC officer cannot be required
to:
• produce to a court documents that have come into the officer's
possession in the course of performing his or her functions under the Bill; or
• divulge or communicate to a court matters that have come to the
officer's notice in the performance of his or her functions under the Bill.
This is intended to preserve the secrecy of information relating to the
ACC's functions in circumstances where a court would otherwise have power to
require the production of documents or the answering of questions that would
disclose that information.
Clause 46(4) provides for exceptions under which a specified officer can be
required to produce the above documents or divulge or communicate the above
matters. These are:
• where the ACC, the CEO, the acting CEO, a member
of the board or an examiner in his or her official capacity is a party to the
relevant proceeding;
• if it is necessary to do so to carry into
effect the provisions of a relevant Act; or
• if it is necessary to do
so for the purposes of a prosecution resulting from an ACC operation or
investigation.
Clause 46(5) defines a ‘relevant Act’ for the purposes of
clause 46 to mean the Commonwealth Act, this Act or a corresponding Act of
another State. This definition is necessary to ensure that the secrecy
obligations in this clause do not prevent the disclosure of information where
this is necessary for the purposes of another Act that forms part of the ACC
co-operative scheme.
Clause 47 Delegation by CEO
This clause allows the CEO to delegate in writing any of his or her powers
under the ACC Act to a member of staff of the ACC who is an SES employee. This
power of delegation affords the CEO flexibility in undertaking administrative
matters, while ensuring that delegated powers are only exercised by
appropriately senior persons.
Clause 48 – Liability for damages
This clause provides that a member of the board is not liable to
proceedings for damages in relation to an act done, or omitted honestly in the
exercise or purported exercise of any function given or expressed under the
Bill.
Clause 49 – Obstructing, hindering or
disrupting ACC or an examiner
This clause makes it an indictable offence to intentionally obstruct or
hinder the ACC or examiner in the performance of the ACC's or examiner's
functions or to intentionally disrupt an examination. The maximum penalty is 500
penalty units or 5 years' imprisonment or both. This offence may be dealt with
summarily under the provisions of section 375 of the
Crimes Act 1900 in certain circumstances. In this case, the
maximum penalty that can be imposed by the court is $5000 or 2 years
imprisonment.
Clause 50 Public meetings and bulletins
This clause provides for public meetings of the board to inform the public
about, or receive submissions in relation to, the performance of the ACC's
functions. The board can also publish bulletins to inform the public about the
performance of its functions. The board is limited in its disclosure in that it
cannot disclose information which could prejudice the safety or reputation of a
person or prejudice the fair trial of a person.
Clause 51 Annual
Report
This clause provides for certain matters to be included in an annual report
prepared by the chair of the board under section 61 of the Commonwealth Act.
This provision, together with comparable provisions in other States' and
Territories' ACC legislation, will ensure that information included in the
annual report under section 61 of the Commonwealth Act relating to the
performance of the ACC's functions under that Act is supplemented with
comparable information about the performance of the ACC's functions under State
and Territory law.
Clause 51(2) requires an annual report under section 61 of the Commonwealth
Act to include:
• descriptions of any special ACC Territory
investigations during the year;
• descriptions of any patterns of
criminal activity and the nature and scope of criminal activity that has come to
the ACC's attention during the year;
• any recommendations for legal
or administrative reform the board considers should be made;
• the
general nature and extent of information provided by the CEO to a law
enforcement agency under the Act;
• the extent to which ACC Territory
investigations have resulted in prosecutions or confiscation proceedings during
the year; and
• numbers and results of court proceedings involving the
ACC in relation to its functions under the Act that were determined during the
year.
Clauses 51(3) and (4) contain provisions to prevent an annual report
identifying persons as having being suspected of, or as having committed
offences (unless the persons have been convicted of those offences) or
identifying a person where this would prejudice a person's safety or reputation
or the fair trial of a person who has been or may be charged with an offence.
The Territory Minister is required to table an annual report within 6
sitting days of receiving the report from the IGC.
Clause 52 Things
done for multiple purposes
Clause 52 – provides that anything done
for the Commonwealth Act does not affect the validity of anything done also for
this Bill.
Clause 53 Regulation-making power
This clause
provides for a regulation-making power under the Bill.
Part 7 Transitional
provisions
Division 7.1 Transitional
Part 7 contains transitional provisions to ensure that the transition from
the NCA to the ACC is as seamless as possible. These transitional provisions are
necessary as a consequence of the commencement of the Commonwealth Act, which
commenced operation on 1 January 2003 and the repeal of the National Crime
Authority (Territory Provisions) Act 1991 by clause 67 of this Bill.
In addition, Schedule 1 contains consequential amendments to a number of ACT
Acts that are necessary because of the replacement of the NCA with the ACC. The
consequential amendments will ensure that those other ACT Acts operate
consistently with the provisions of the new Bill.
Clause 54 Definitions for div 7.1
This clause sets out
definitions that apply for the purposes of the transitional provisions in
division 7.1 of the Bill.
Clause 55 Certain investigations taken to be special
investigations
This clause deems an ACC Territory investigation that relates to a matter
that was the subject of an NCA investigation that had been commenced but not
completed before 1 January 2003 to be a special ACC investigation. This
means that if the board consents to the ACC conducting an ACC Territory
investigation into a matter that previously had been the subject of an
incomplete investigation under the National Crime Authority (Territory
Provisions) Act 1991, it will be unnecessary for the board to make a new
determination authorising the use of special powers under the Bill.
Clause 56 Assembling and giving evidence obtained by
the NCA
This clause imposes on the ACC the obligation under subclause 37 (1) of the
Bill to assemble and give to the relevant prosecuting authority evidence that
the NCA had obtained before 1 January 2003 but had not assembled and given to
the relevant prosecuting authority under section 6(1) of the National Crime
Authority (Territory Provisions) Act 1991 as if that
evidence had been obtained by the ACC in carrying out an ACC
operation/investigation.
Clause 57 Limitation on challenges to validity of
references
This clause ensures that where a matter was referred to the NCA for
investigation before 1 January 2003, the reference continues to be protected
from challenges, under section 8 of the National Crime Authority (Territory
Provisions) Act 1991 after the repeal of that Act by the Bill. Section 8
protects a reference from challenge on the grounds that any necessary approval
had not been obtained or was not lawfully given.
Clause 58 Arrangements to obtain information or
intelligence
This clause provides that an arrangement in force immediately before
1 January 2003 under section 11 of the National Crime Authority
(Territory Provisions) Act 1991 has effect as if it had been made
under clause 42 of the Bill.
Clause 59 Things seized under search
warrants
This clause ensures that where things are seized under a warrant under
section 12 of the National Crime Authority (Territory Provisions) Act
1991 are in the ACC's possession, the obligations under subclauses
32(9) and (10) of the Bill regarding the retention and return of things seized
under warrant apply to those things.
Clause 60 Directions about publication
This clause provides that where a direction was in force under section
15(4) of the National Crime Authority (Territory Provisions) Act 1991
immediately before 1 January 2003:
• the provisions in
clauses 21(12), and (13), regarding the revocation of directions and the offence
of contravening a non-publication direction contained in clause 21(16)
apply to that direction; as if it were a direction under clause 21 (10) relating
to the publication of information; and
• clause 21 (14) and (15) so
far as they relate to the CEO of the ACC, apply to evidence that is the subject
of such a direction. These provisions enable a court to obtain evidence that is
the subject of a non-publication direction in certain circumstances.
Clause 61 Disclosure of summons or notice
This clause ensures that if a non-disclosure notation included in a summons
or notice to produce documents was in force under section 17A of the National
Crime Authority (Territory Provisions) Act 1991 immediately before 1 January
2003, the notation is effective and it is an offence under clause 25 of the Bill
to make a disclosure in contravention of the notation. If there is an ACC
operation/investigation relating to the same matter to which the NCA
investigation related, the provisions in clause 24(4) and (5) relating to
the automatic cancellation of a notation apply.
Clause 62 Witness
protection
This clause ensures that arrangements in force immediately before 1 January
2003 under section 23 of the National Crime Authority (Territory Provisions)
Act 1991 made by a member or hearing officer of the NCA
to protect witnesses from harm or intimidation have effect as if they had
been made under clause 29 of the Bill.
Clause 63 Administrative
arrangements in relation to NCA
This clause enables arrangements between the ACT and the Commonwealth that
were in force immediately before 1 January 2003 under section 27(b) of the
National Crime Authority (Territory Provisions) Act 1991 under
which the Territory makes persons available to hold office as members of the NCA
or to perform services for the NCA to have effect as if those arrangements had
been made under section 43 of the Bill.
Clause 64 Administrative
arrangements under Witness Protection Act 1996
This clause enables arrangements between the chief police officer and the
NCA that were in force immediately before 1 January 2003 under section 25 of the
Witness Protection Act 1996 to have effect as if those arrangements
had been made under the Bill between the chief police officer and the CEO.
Clause 65 Secrecy obligations
This clause ensures that former officials, being persons who were at any
time subject to the secrecy obligations under section 29 of the National
Crime Authority (Territory Provisions) Act 1991, are subject to the
secrecy obligations outlined in clause 46(2),(3) and (4) of the Bill.
Clause 66 Regulations modifying pt 7
This clause enables the making of regulations to modify the operation of
Part 7 to provide for any matter that is not, or is not in the Executive’s
opinion adequately dealt with in this part. The section expires one year after
its commencement.
Division 7.2 Repeals and consequential
amendments
Clause 67 Repeals
This clause repeals the National Crime Authority (Territory Provisions)
Act 1991 No 75 and the National Crime Authority (Territory
Provisions) Regulations 1995 No 39.
Clause 68 Legislation amended-sch1
This clause provides for the amendment of legislation by Schedule 1 of the
Bill.
Division 7.3 Miscellaneous
Clause 69 Expiry of pt7
This clause provides for the expiration of Part 7, other than section 66,
two years after the day it commences.
Clause 70 Declared law for Legislation Act, s
88
This clause declares Part 7 to be law to which the Legislation Act, section
88 applies. This has the effect of continuing the declaratory or validating
effect of the transitional provisions after the repeal of those provisions.
Schedule 1 Consequential
amendments
Part 1.1 Administration (Interstate Agreements) Act 1997
This
part omits the reference to the “National Crime Authority Act 1984
(Cwlth) section 8” with “Australian Crime Commission
Act 2002 (Cwlth), section 7”, in Schedule 1, clause 1 of the
Bill. It has also omitted the reference to “references issued by the
responsible ACT Minister...” because such references are no longer made
under the new ACC legislation. These have been replaced in effect by
determinations of the board under clause 11 of the Bill.
Part 1.2 Gambling and Racing Control Act
1999
This part substitutes the previous reference to “National Crime
Authority” in section 37 (d)(vii) with “the Australian
Crime Commission”.
Part 1.3 Spent Convictions Act 2000
This part replaces references to the “the National Crime
Authority” and “the Australian Bureau of Criminal
Intelligence” contained respectively in paragraphs (d) and (e) in the
dictionary definition of “law enforcement agency”, with “the
Australian Crime Commission”. The Australian Bureau of Criminal
Intelligence has also been incorporated into the ACC.
Part 1.4 Taxation Administration Act 1999
This part substitutes the previous reference to “national crime
authority” in section 97 (d) (ix) with “the Australian
Crime Commission”.
Part 1.5 Witness Protection Act 1996
This part replaces the previous reference to “chairperson of the
national crime authority” contained in section 3 of the definition of
“approved authority”, with “the chief executive officer
of the Australian Crime Commission”.
Dictionary
The dictionary defines certain words and expressions for the purposes of
the Bill. This includes definitions for the following key terms:
"ACC operation/investigation” means an ACC Territory
intelligence operation or an ACC Territory investigation. This covers both the
ACC's function in relation to intelligence operations and its function in
relation to investigating relevant criminal activity.
Relevant criminal activity is defined in the Commonwealth Act to mean any
circumstances implying, or any allegations, that a serious and organised crime
may have been, may be being, or may in future be, committed against a
Commonwealth, State or Territory law. This definition is applied to the Bill
under the operation of clause 6.
"ACC Territory intelligence operation” means an
intelligence operation that the ACC is undertaking under clause 8(b). This
covers the ACC's function in undertaking intelligence operations in relation to
relevant criminal activity relating to ACT offences.
"ACC Territory investigation” means an investigation
that the ACC is conducting under clause 8(a). This covers the ACC's function in
conducting investigations in relation to relevant criminal activity relating to
ACT offences.
"intelligence operation” means the collection,
correlation, analysis or dissemination of criminal information and intelligence
relating to a relevant criminal activity. Intelligence operation has a broad
meaning to ensure that the ACC is able to undertake fully its criminal
intelligence role under ACT law.
"serious and organised crime” is defined to cover a
wide range of serious offences that are the same as those contained in the
equivalent definition in the Commonwealth Act, except for certain offences under
the Commonwealth Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 that are not relevant in an
ACT context. The offences listed in the definition of "serious and organised
crime" in the Bill mirror the offences that the former NCA could investigate,
with the addition of offences that involve firearms and cyber crime. Cyber
crime has been added to enable the ACC to respond to this emerging issue.
Firearms offences have been added to the list to ensure that the ACC has a clear
power to investigate the illegal trafficking of firearms.
The definition of serious and organised crime covers a listed offence that
is punishable by three years' imprisonment or more and that is not committed in
the course of a genuine industrial dispute of a specified kind.
The wide range of serious offences included within the definition of
"serious and organised crime" will ensure that the ACC has a broad basis on
which to undertake its investigatory and criminal intelligence functions.
The definition of serious and organised crime covers a listed serious
offence where there are also specified organised crime elements involved in the
offence in question. In particular, the offence must also:
• involve
two or more offenders and substantial planning and organisation; and
• involve, or be an offence of a kind that ordinarily involves, the
use of sophisticated methods and techniques; and
• be an offence that
is committed, or is of a kind that is ordinarily committed, in conjunction with
other offences of a like kind.
"special ACC operation/investigation” means an ACC
Territory intelligence operation or an ACC Territory investigation that the
board has determined to be a special operation or investigation. This is an
important definition as the ACC can only access its special powers, such as
search warrants and examinations, as part of a special ACC
operation/investigation. It cannot access these powers for other ACC
investigations or operations authorised by the board.
[Index]
[Search]
[Download]
[Bill]
[[Help]]