Commonwealth Consolidated Acts

[Index] [Table] [Search] [Search this Act] [Notes] [Noteup] [Previous] [Next] [Download] [Help]

DEFENCE FORCE DISCIPLINE ACT 1982 - SECT 135

Trial by Defence Force magistrate

  (1)   A Defence Force magistrate shall try a charge in accordance with the following provisions:

  (a)   before the Defence Force magistrate commences to hear the evidence on the charge, the Defence Force magistrate shall ask the accused person whether he or she pleads guilty or not guilty to the charge and, if the accused person pleads guilty and the Defence Force magistrate is satisfied that the accused person understands the effect of that plea, the Defence Force magistrate shall convict the accused person;

  (b)   if the accused person pleads not guilty or if the Defence Force magistrate is not satisfied that the accused person, in pleading guilty, understands the effect of that plea, the Defence Force magistrate shall record a plea of not guilty and proceed to hear the evidence on the charge;

  (c)   if the Defence Force magistrate, after hearing the evidence on the charge adduced by the prosecution, rules that that evidence is insufficient to support the charge, the Defence Force magistrate shall dismiss the charge;

  (d)   if the Defence Force magistrate, after hearing the evidence on the charge adduced by the prosecution, rules that that evidence is sufficient to support the charge, the Defence Force magistrate shall proceed with the trial;

  (e)   if the Defence Force magistrate finds the accused person not guilty, the Defence Force magistrate shall acquit the accused person;

  (f)   if the Defence Force magistrate finds the accused person guilty, the Defence Force magistrate shall convict the accused person;

  (g)   if the Defence Force magistrate convicts the accused person, the Defence Force magistrate shall take action under Part   IV in relation to the convicted person.

  (2)   Where an accused person:

  (a)   refuses to plead; or

  (b)   does not plead intelligibly;

the Defence Force magistrate shall record a plea of not guilty and proceed accordingly in accordance with subsection   (1).

  (3)   Where, under paragraph   (1)(a), an accused person pleads guilty to a service offence that is one (other than the first) of 2 or more charges stated in the charge sheet in the alternative, the Defence Force magistrate shall:

  (a)   if the Director of Military Prosecutions notifies the Defence Force magistrate that he or she does not object to the acceptance of the plea--accept the plea and proceed accordingly in accordance with subsection   (1); or

  (b)   in any other case--record a plea of not guilty and proceed accordingly in accordance with subsection   (1).

  (4)   Where an accused person who has pleaded not guilty withdraws his or her plea and pleads guilty, the Defence Force magistrate shall, if the Defence Force magistrate is satisfied that the accused person understands the effect of that plea, substitute a plea of guilty for the plea of not guilty and proceed accordingly in accordance with subsection   (1).

  (4A)   Nothing in subsection   (1) shall be taken to require the Defence Force magistrate to give either a ruling of the kind referred to in paragraph   (1)(c) or a ruling of the kind referred to in paragraph   (1)(d) unless:

  (a)   the accused person has submitted that the Defence Force magistrate should give a ruling of the first - mentioned kind; or

  (b)   the interests of justice require that the Defence Force magistrate should give a ruling of the first - mentioned kind.

  (5)   A Defence Force magistrate, before taking action under paragraph   (1)(g), shall hear evidence relevant to the determination of what action should be taken.



AustLII: Copyright Policy | Disclaimers | Privacy Policy | Feedback